Pakistan's taxing, federation, equality (split from A critical look at the economy)

[yazdi]

Re: A critical look at the Pak economy

@Sa1eem

Brother, I know that you are not asking for link, but you are asking for source. Anyhow, I did not put any link for what I posted because what I wrote was not ‘Article published anywhere on net’ that I was quoting (as some ignorants might be thinking as they do not understand simple English or even figures) but what I wrote was my own. Now, you tell me that how anyone other than ignorant would ask for a link from someone for someone’s own writing?

I stopped arguing here on this thread because I realised the intellectual level of argument. Just imagine that there is a person that does not understand simple English, figures, tax year, percentage, GDP, Per capita income, direct and indirect taxes, contribution, collection, or anything worthwhile, still like to argue.

A person that does not even know that when quoting ‘tax collection figures’ one have to quote year of collection, because figures change from year to year, than what one can argue intelligently with such person? It is irony of Pakistan that there are people who like to teach others what they themselves do not understand, and that is the reason that many in Pakistan are misguided :).

Anyhow, you asked for source of information. So source is:
1: Combined Finance and Revenue department Accounts, Government of Pakistan.
2: Planning and Development department, Government of Sindh.

Nevertheless, the figures that I quoted was for 3 financial years, (97-98, 98-99, 99-00) and it was mentioned at ‘National Conference on NFC awards’ held in July 2006, that is fortunately available on NET (as many things are not available on NET). You will find the figures presented by Birohi … on page 3 and 4.

http://sindh.ws/index2.php?option=com_content&do_pdf=1&id=14

Thanks for posting the link of the propoganda site “Sindh.ws” created by some Sindhi sepratist where you take your figures…

Let me expose the lies you have been spreading…

Your propoganda site claims:

Sindh share of Income tax 86.40% of the total during the years 1997-2000…page 3 of pdf file you have posted

Official cbr site reveals

http://www.cbr.gov.pk/YearBook/2001-02/StatisticalTables.htm

Open item 9 from the link to open year wise total income tax collection region wise…

Total share of Sindh in total income tax collection for the years you have mentioned are as follows:

1. 1997/98 Rs. 59.814 billion out of total Rs. 97.135 billion 61%

2. 1998/99 Rs. 60.905 billion out of total Rs.103.189 billion 59%

3. 1999/00 Rs. 54.208 billion out of total Rs.105.337 billion 51%

4. 2000/01 Rs 65.081 billion out of total Rs. 117.469 billion 55%

5. 2001/02 Rs 67.025 billion out of total Rs 136.542 billion 49%

These figures are from official cbr site and not from any bogus propoganda site…nothing near to 86.40% on your bogus link…

What your propoganda site fails to mention is in these figures all kind of withholding taxes are included..example on export/import…I think I do not need to repeat again as I have explained in detail in my previous post…

Similarly I can assure you all the other figures on your propoganda site are also bogus and fictitious…pack of lies…and don’t try to fool the forum readers that this site is some kind of official Sind government site…

Let the readers decide who is spreading lies and who is an intellectual…and let them decide also how much you understand the subject under discussion instead of self gloryfying yourself…I do not need your endorsement…and I do not want to mention what I think of you…like you have done !!!

Better luck next time…

Just imagine that there is a person that does not understand simple English

Example of your expertise in English…:smack: