Pakistani players' mental frailties & lack of self-belief

Agree with the bold parts. Test cricket requires more skill and temperament and confidence plays a big part in a team winning or losing at this level

Pakistan played like they did not believe - Osman Samiuddin

Pakistan’s grip on this Test was going the minute they took a 206-run lead in the first innings. This morning, with Australia effectively 80 for 8 they knew they had lost it. Hollywood rehab clinics have fewer mental frailties than this side.

Like in Melbourne last week, never at any point did Pakistan believe they could win this Test and for that alone they deserved the sorry fate that befell them at the SCG. Publicly Australia spoke yesterday as if they could win this. Pakistan, publicly and privately, only wished they could win this.

The morning session was bizarre and instructive, possibly the worst session of leadership of a side in such a dominant position. Sides giving up 200-plus leads in Tests had only won five times ever after all. But Mohammad Yousuf thought Michael Hussey was Bradman and Peter Siddle that Bradman of tailenders, Jason Gillespie, and that Australia were 700 for 3. Effectively they were 80 for 8, Hussey had been dropped thrice and Pakistan began with eight men on the boundary. A more winning lost cause is difficult to conjure.

Yousuf has surprised people with his leadership here, but today was the worst of him; defensive, unimaginative, sluggish and unwilling to take risk. Inzamam-ul-Haq’s beard is there and maybe the worst of his captaincy spirit was also floating around. From there, whatever the chase, the writing was being written on the wall.

And then nothing matters in these chases for Pakistan; people talk of flat pitches, overhead conditions, surviving the new ball and playing out the old. But the only thing that matters is that it’s them. They could be chasing 90 on cement, with a tennis ball and in 45 degrees heat, but this batting line-up will find a way to get out for less. Who the opponent was didn’t really matter. They were called Panickstan here once, long ago. A regurgitation is in order.

Three times this year they have done it - in Sri Lanka, in New Zealand and now. This will hurt the most because it isn’t every day that you dominate Australia, any Australia side, for three days and lose on the last. Australia, any Australia side, still know how to win and more importantly they know how not to throw matches away. Their players are brought up doing it. Peter Siddle’s innings is shining testament to that ethic. Pakistan’s tail presents a sorry contrast. Pakistan know simply how to play well every now and again, not to win, or avoid losing. That might never come and if it does it will take time.

The Test was lost at many other stages and that is the wretchedness of Pakistan’s cricket that they could’ve won it still. **They should’ve shut out Australia with their first innings, instead batting like lemons and not posting an insurmountable lead. Yousuf keeps talking about how much Twenty20 cricket is destroying Pakistan’s batsmen and with the kind of batting seen here - not least his own dismissals - it is a persuasive argument. **

Kamran Akmal dropped the Test four times himself through the second innings. He has been better this last year but he should’ve been dropped a few years ago; if he keeps getting selected, there is every chance now and again this may happen. His batting was crucial in New Zealand, but it’s been ill-judged here. Misbah-ul-Haq, Faisal Iqbal - should they really be in this line-up?

And yet still it boggles the mind. It will do for many days. Knowing all this, feeling all along that they may lose this, to see it play itself out as it did is deeply affecting. To watch such an implosion, from such a position, can break you. Who knows what living it can do. Still the question: how have they lost it? Everyone knows but nobody understands, least of all the side itself.

Pakistan played like they did not believe | Cricket Features | Australia v Pakistan 2009/10 | Cricinfo.com

Pakistan talented but short on temperament: IMRAN KHAN

Pakistan’s former captain Imran Khan has said that the national team had squandered a golden opportunity to beat Australia in their own backyard in so many years

“Our team has a lot of talent but they are short on temperament and this was visible in the way we allowed Australia to comeback and win the test in Sydney,” Imran said.

The former great, who once took 12 wickets to lead Pakistan to a big win in Sydney, said until there was a proper domestic system to utilise the talents available in the country, Pakistan would continue to suffer and lose the pressure matches.

“Temperament in a player is only built when a country’s domestic structure is strong and produces tough competition. Our domestic system is run by a mafia which refuses to allow positive changes in it,” Imran lamented.

He pointed out that nowhere in the world were commercial units like banks and government institutions allowed to take part in domestic first class cricket except in Pakistan.

“I don’t understand what these banks are doing in domestic cricket. They are like a mafia who wouldn’t allow any changes to the basic domestic structure and they are ruining Pakistan cricket,” he said.

Imran said unless the domestic structure was changed and improved the standard and performances of Pakistan team would not improve.

Imran added that he was disappointed to see Pakistan lose the test after having bowled out the home side for just 127 runs in their first innings.

“I promise you lot of improvement in Pakistan cricket, the day our party comes into power and is in the government.”

Another former captain, Rameez Raja said he blamed captain Muhammad Yousuf for the defeat. “It was a very poor captaincy from Yousuf and he showed a very negative mindset in the Test. It is hard to understand his strategy on the fourth day of the test,” Rameez said.

He pointed out that a captain leads from the front and when he shows a negative mindset, then it rubs off on the players as well. “I blame Yousuf for the defeat because of his defensive approach. But what I don’t understand is even if he was making a blunder on the field what was the support staff doing? Why didn’t they advice him to change his plan immediately and attack the Australians?” he added.

Pakistan squandered a golden opportunity: Imran Khan - Top Stories - Cricket - Sports - The Times of India

Re: Pakistani players' mental frailties & lack of self-belief

So many questions but no answers. PCB was supposed to have a constitution by now and have elections for a new governing body. But after 2-3 years of promises, we haven't seen anything done. And I doubt anything will change. PCB/government is hopeless.

Re: Pakistani players' mental frailties & lack of self-belief

Imran wants the Aussie domestic structure in Pakistan...Miandad doesent. Ramiz now wants clubs and regional/city teams but a few years ago when he was leading Allied Bank in domestic cricket...Raja was one of the biggest supporters of banks having their own teams.

Saron ka apna matlab hai.

Re: Pakistani players' mental frailties & lack of self-belief

Belief comes when there are leaders in the team. A Cricket team is divided in three parts batting, bowling and captaincy. Our bowling is doing well because there is always someone to take the center stage and responsibility on his shoulder. We are still searching for someone to lead the team with the bat after Inzamam's departure from world cricket and captaincy changes so many times that we never get to see a leader. In fact, haven't seen since Wasim Akram.

Lets not reduce the loss to drop catches. The disaster was bigger than that. I lost count of drop catches while watching the India, Sri lanka ODI series. There were too many to remember.

Our loss has exposed our biggest weakness. Pakistani team does not know how to close the game.

All have reasonable arguments

Miandad argues that the banks/organisations provide a stable and regular income to our domestic players - which might not be the case with a regional set-up - most of whom come from very poor backgrounds. Australian players for instance do not face the same financial constraints as our players. Hence they can afford to have only 6 teams in their domestic cricket - Pura Cup formerly Sheffield Shield - Each of the six state teams plays an annual double round-robin series of home and away 4-day matches against every other team. Points are awarded for each match and the top two teams play a 5-day final.

Gone are the days when Pakistan's cricketers (40-50%) came from educated, and privileged backgrounds - Imran & Majid, The Rajas (Wasim and Rameez), Zaheer Abbas, Asif Iqbal etc. Most of our present players come from very humble beginnings and hence they need some kind of financial security as well.

Whether our domestic cricket is run by organisations or regions, we must not compromise on quality. Have few teams that are strong and competitive; maybe a maximam of 8 teams. If necessary have a performance-based tier system of 12 teams divided into two leagues of 6 each with most of the international players coming from the top 6.