Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

Its your life and your choice but If I were you I would try my best to avoid marrying a non-Pakistani due to a variety of factors like culture, language barrier, social norms, traditions, family, future life etc. It may seem rosy now but if you are bent upon marrying this guy do a proper family background check first and do consider how your view your next 20/30 years with him.

Lets not discuss exceptions shall we?

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

Considering the amount of people I know that were (and currently are) being raised by parents of the same background, and who don't know much about their own culture despite BOTH parents being from the same background......I don't consider this an exception due to my personal observations. This may be different for you based on your location/background/social group etc......but for me personally, this is not an exception.

Having a spouse of the same exactly ethnicity doesn't somehow guarantee that the children will learn to know and respect their own culture. And on the flip side, having a spouse of a different ethnicity doesn't mean that the kids will not learn about their culture either. Instead of trying to predict the future behavior of the spouse when it comes to teaching children about culture....OP should consider how much effort SHE HERSELF is willing to put into teaching her future chidren about her own culture.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

We met at my first semester in university and were friends through most of it.He was a Catholic but highly interested in Islamic studies and would always ask me questions about Islam. I don't want to go into much detail.But later on ,we fell for each other even though I refused to admit it.

The aunties don't worry me couldn't care less what they think, but yeah it's probably the grief they will give my mother. Like I said before, I'm Mirpuri.Most of marriages in the British Mirpuri community are between first cousins.Parents marry their children to the children of their own brothers and sisters from back home Mirpur.Even marrying someone from outside the caste is frowned upon.

Nice to see that it can work.I'm happy for you :D

My brother has always been totally against interracial relationships.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

dont do it. seriously dont. get over him. you will not be happy in the future. i am sure you are a wonderful person and will inshallah find yourself a religious, charming, and educated pakistani.

this is just infatuation right now. 10 years from now (if u are even still together [harsh i know]) you are going to hate your life. you are going to wish ur hubby knew about pakistani culture, knew urdu, understood things the way u did, have the same upbringing as u did, have that fun sasural life, the fun family life.

if u are madly in love, then well i wouldnt know. but if there is ANY doubt in your mind, please please dont make the mistake of doing this.

i feel like im so mean saying all this but i just really want to help

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

you guys have a lot of misconceptions about westerns

  1. Not all goris ignore their family and runaway.
  2. Culture, language and religion is learned with time. I'm sure as others have said there are Pakistani couples who do not know their language or culture but are trying hard now as adults so they can teach their kids.

I know it may seem hard with all these negative views from strangers but you decided on going into a relationship. A relationship is commitment and if you won't even fight for him or give him a chance for your family to like him then perhaps you should reconsider this marriage.
Culture and languages can always be taught.
Please don't give up

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???

Thanks for the replies! He is Italian and they are not like other goras they are social, extremely family oriented and usually a faithful people,quite similar to Pakistani culture.To say that Italiansare family-oriented is an understatement; family is everything in Italy.

I just need to convince my parents to let me marry him.They 'd prefer me to marry my cousin back home and if not , then a Pakistani Mirpuri guy,nothing outside of that.It’s going to be difficult :frowning:

I’m going to put up a fight for him first :hoonh:

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

A part of my wants to say you should have known this was coming

The other half wants to say Islamically, you can not be wronged.

All I can do I guess is wish you the best

(Being a fellow Kashmiri I totally understand where you come from)

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

I'll bet no-one in your family or close circle has married out.. These are the same tired old cliches ppl believe before they ever come across interracial relationships.. There are PLENTY of successful marriages between different races and cultures nowadays..

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

Ha....I didn't realize we had fortune tellers on GS who could predict the future with such certainty!

You don't come across as being "mean". With all due respect, you come across as being VERY ignorant.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

^
Lol, harsh but true.

What ethnic background is your husband?

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

So anyone who does not agrees with your POV is ignorant and worthy of snide comments?

You married out of your race...fine! Good for you! Last I checked everyone was entitled to their opinion. Lets not start attacking each other.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

^It's ignorant to say they can't work out when there are now many examples showing they can..

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

looks like you new here bro............ just sit back and enjoy.......:D

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

In the Desi community there are a very low level of mixed marriages thus making "many examples" one that is statistically invalid.

I think in this situation it comes down to the individual person and their preferences and that is it.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

^I know of literally dozens of mixed marriages (inc my own parents, several cousins and literally one child from EVERY single family in our circle).. Granted it's not representative but it's possible to see they can work.. I'm not saying they always do cos obviously they don't.. but it is possible to marry a 'foreigner' and be happy..

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

i am by no means ignorant. i am just being realistic. there have been inter racial marriages in my family as well. but many of them failed and the only one that lasted was because the pakistani of the couple was barely pakistani himself.

i am not a fortune teller. only Allah knows best. but i do know that if something will cause a lot of problems and fighting, then it is only worth it if you are 100 percent sure this guy is right for you. obviously she has doubts and if there is a doubt, i would like to give my honest and true perspective on this because not many people are so straightforward.

i see that she is willing to pursue this and will fight for it as she mentioned in her last comment. i guess she has decided that it is worth it for her. while inter racial marriages do work, they are most definitely harder and stressful. you can disagree but this is what i have observed and what just makes sense to me.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

^ Deewani

You may have seen many mixed marriages fail, but there are many successful mixed marriages on this forum and all around the world!

Its unfair to say it will not work out just because of what your family have experienced.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???

With all do respect, this is one of the most ridiculous things I’ve heard in a long time. How do you know she’s not going to be happy in 10 years? Magic 8 ball?

For every doomed/failed interracial love match you come up with, I’m pretty sure I can match it with 10 more that have succeeded. It all boils down to the two people at hand, and whether or not they are committed to making it work or not. Like its already been mentioned above, if he has converted on his own and is ready to live his life as Muslim, then why not? If anything, the loves of their future children will be even more beautiful and enriched because of their father’s background. And they’ll be gorgeous to boot too…mixed race kids always are :chai:

OP, I say go for it…your family loves you, and will come around I’m sure

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

She's not ignorant b/c she doesn't agree with my POV. She's ignorant b/c in that specific post I quoted, she pretty much guaranteed OP a miserable life if OP married a non-Pakistani. I'm not a mind reader. I go strictly by the words that's typed up. And the specific words the poster choose to convey her POV made her come acorss as someone who's very ignorant.

Its one thing to state your POV.....but if someone is going to state what he/she thinks is going to happen 10 years from now with so much passion and confidence.....then we're moving away from sharing POV's and into predicting the future.

Re: Pakistani girls marrying outside their ethnicity/culture???????

Now this is something I will agree with! What you wrote in the previous post....and what's written above are totally different. The message conveyed behind the 2 posts are totally different. I will 2nd everything you have written here and very much agree with the part in bold. My issue with your previous post was the way your worded it.....in a way essentially saying that OP is guaranteed to be miserable if she married a non-Pakistani. That's not a realistic view. But what you wrote here.....this is a much more realistic assessment (ie. inter-racial marriages can work but they're much harder due to the cultural differences).