Re: Our Stupid Nation - Pakistanese
Some members on this board have constantly been trying to create the impression as if all the extremism is rooted in one cultural group. My point is, we, together with Sindhis and Baluchis, neither have the power, nor resources, nor intellectual sophistication to coin such concepts as Pan-Islamisn, organized and persistent and large-scale Jehad, Political Islam, Sino-Muslim nexus, Bomb, etc. Neither we have the resources or the organizational skill to let a cobweb of militant groups to sprout on and operate from our land.
Moreover, you should study the growth and evolution of radical/extremist religious ideologies and militancy in the Subcontinent over the past two centuries and you will see that almost all such ideologies sprung from the soil of the Subcontinent. The reason is, Muslim community, that had developed over the second milinuim CE in Hindustan was in a quest for identity. Pan-Islamist, radical-Islamist served their need and linked them to civilizations outside.
If you study the political history of Pashtuns, Sindhis, and Baluchis, you woundn’t find a single religious movement with Pan-Islamist aspirations.
Here it would be relevant to mention that during Taliban days, Dr. Israr Ahmad, head of Tanzim-i-Islami, a radical religious movement based in Lahore, used to visit our areas telling people “In a Hadith, it has beed said that the movement and power of Islam would re-emerge from this region and would spread in all directions. Pakistan would serve as the mind/brain for this movement and people of Khurasan as soldiers”. By Khurasan, he meant Afghanistan and Pashtun areas. (It is another matter that he was quick to denounce his Jehadi views after 9/11.)
I will also remind you that there had been formed an Afghanistan Defence Council of which Mualana Samuil-Haq etc. and a number of retired generals were the “influential members”. Also, before 9/11, you would see it written on every wall that “Jehad ki tarbiat Ham sai hasil karain”. How is it possible in a state that some groups start arming and training people in militancy openly?
Still some members here have the audacity to blame it entirely on one cultural group.
Please, don’t mind but I’ve an impression about some Muslims of the Subcontinent that they would turn every thing into “shop-keeping” i.e. “dukandari”. They would turn Islam into “dukandari”, democracy into dukandari", communism into “dukandari”, liberalism into “dukandari”, terrorism into “dukandari” , and you name it!
Now our people have had a different kind of social development i.e. they would stand for their convictions and would make sacrifices for it. Before our unfortunate association with the Muslims of the Subcontinent, there was no conflict in our being Muslims and our being Pashtuns. Both co-existed peacefuly. But these “shop-keepers” would come and subvert the ideological morings of our society by telling us that Islam is primary and our culture is secondary. Our society too is facing peculier circumstances. Feudalism has cumbled (feudalism was already very weak) in our society and tribal stuctures are crumbling. And as the old values are becoming redundant, the “Islamic Shop-keepers”, with support from the ruling structures and media, are there to sell their subversive ideologies and values to masses. Counter and divergent views and approaches to life have already been blocked.
I lament the day when we came to be associated with Subcontinental Muslims. If they couldn’t transform themselves, our disassociation from them would be better. It would save our society of confusion, internal instability, and destruction.
Believe me, provincial governments are just **high-profile local governments **with no powers whatsoever. It is the military, economic, political, religious, and intellecual elite of Punjab and to certain degree Karachi calling the shots and defining and shaping the mainstrean culture, thought, and world-view of the so-called Pakistani Society. They have the media, the resources, the political and administrative authority, and the sophistication to do all this.
As for Qazi Hussain Ahmad, probably, you don’t know that the Markazi Majlisi Shura of Jummaat i Islami at Mansura Lahore has the deciding powers. They gay could not utter a word against Kalabagh Dam openly despite the fact that Nowshera is his constituency lest Punjabi menbers of Majlis-i-Shura are antagonized/annoyed.