opinions...

I have been asked by a frd to get opinions on this situation:

He told me he has been going out with his gf for about 5 yrs now. He is 21 yrs old that girl is his high school sweetheart. He wants to marry her in the near future but feels that there are some issues that make him stop and re think abt his future with her. Whenever him n his gf get into small arguments, she swears at his mother. She also swears at his father, brother and his sister. She gets crazy and says really hurtful things. He told me that whenever he goes to a family member’s house, she gets crazy and swears at them too. She sometimes forbids him from going over to his cousin’s houses. That guy loves his brother a lot and he has to hear that girl call him stupid things that really hurt him. She does not like it when he stays out later than 12 am, and even if he does stay out later, she starts ringing off his phone non stop. She does not allow him to go to parties or clubs or anywhere that involves mingling with girls. He claims that he does not see that girl getting along with his family. He really cares abt his family. He wants to know wat he should do? Should he break things off with her? or hope that she will change in the future? He wants to know, is this relationship worth keeping?

Re: opinions...

LOL! RUNNNN!!!!!

HELL YES!

Run as far away as he can from her.

Re: opinions...

Tough situation, really a hard decision. Dont know what to tell you.

Khi khi khi

Re: opinions...

She's not worth it. Walk away and find someone better.

Hmmm the girl has some serious problems but otherwise if she is a good girl like if he truly loves him and is faithful to him then he should have a talk with her and tell her that how much her abusive language & her possessiveness affects him. Let's see what she has to say then. If she show willingness to change herself for him then it's a good sign and they should start working on it. If she does not cooperate and does not show any willingness to change then I think he should say goodbye to her. Swearing is something I believe she has seen since her childhood , for so many people it's not a big deal because they have grown up seeing people swearing at each other but people can change. My inlaws very frequently used words like zalil , kameena for each other too and it was normal for them lol !

One thing that came to my mind was that how much controlling the guy is ? may be he is same way or even more controlling and possessive than she is and what ever she is doing is in reaction to his behaviour.

It's better for both of them to discus things out before ending the relationship. Always give relationships a chance before ending , you never know what you might loose in a hasty decision.

Re: opinions...

might b he was jst teasing her ......:D

my exact sentiments.

but i think he should stick with her and taste the essence of hell which he would face anyways by going to parties and mingling with non-mehram larkian :)

If your friend has THIS MANY concerns about her, why is he even contemplating marriage with her in the first place? When you want to marry someone, I would think that you'd KNOW FOR SURE that you want to spend the rest of your life with that person. If he's asking you to get anonymous opinions, that indicates he has serious doubts about this girl, so he's not ready for marriage.

She's verbally abusive and that can leave deeper scars than physical abuse. If she can so easily lose control around him, she can do the same around his family, thus potentially destroying relationships. Although marriage would change things and you can't always stay out late after midnight, she does seem possessive and maybe this stems from some insecurity. I don't think her anger management problems developed overnight or developed when they started going out. They are a part of her and who she is and that's really hard to change unless the individual makes a proactive effort.

If he's that hurt by her, why is he in a relationship with her? He's only 21 and there's no shortage of girls. What does this say about him? Does he respect himself enough? Does he have low self-esteem that he wants to marry someone who doesn't even give him basic respect? Has he talked to her about how her behavior makes him feel? If he already has talked to her and she only seems to be getting worse, then there's only so much you can do. What's next? Counseling? No, he shouldn't marry her, not if he he's still having these issues. He needs to weigh the pros and cons and maybe give this more time and get some space to sort out his thoughts.

Re: opinions…

^ I agree with you ! there are plenty of fish in the sea.

But I have a strong feeling that there is more to this story otherwise guys really don’t take so much from a girl . At 21 most of the guys would not even think about marriage. There is definitely more to this story , this guy has some negative traits too and the girl has some positive too. Otherwise a guy considering such a girl for marriage does not sound normal to me.

btw nice to see you Magic8Ball after such a long time :wink:

Lol......what kind of relationship is this?

Is she his gf or his amma????

Re: opinions...

Why not talk all these things with the girl concerned?It might clear up some issues.Maybe she feels insecure when he goes to parties and all.

He gets to party and mingle with non-mehram larkiyaan now, and later he would be in hell with all top models, actresses and other 'baysharam' larkiyaan. How is that fair?!

Gets insecure and swears at his parents? I don't mean no disrespect but the bych would have lost at least 4 teeth if I was that guy.

Re: opinions...

she seems to have issues. prehaps she needs help controlling her anger.

Re: opinions...

No offence but your friend sounds pretty pathetic!!! He says he loves and cares for his family but lets some dumb b*tch swear at them... wow, never seen this kind of love and respect for parents!!
The girl sounds like a keeper!!! lmao!! How would she react if he bad mouthed HER family??? A girl that can be like this BEFORE marriage is capable of A LOT more after marriage....

Re: opinions...

^ Bravo.

thats what I don't understand. Why is the guy putting up with this ? why after all this he is still considering her for marriage ?

what made her swear ? she would not have just started off swearing at his parents for no good reason.

itna shareef koi nahi hota kay without reason itna sab kuch bardasht karey esp when they are not even married !!!!

there is alot more to this than what has been posted !

Re: opinions...

wow, i shoudve married him....such a walkover.

he needs to run like the wind.

he seems so loyal and loving, awwwww, wish i was single. the girl is deff crazy, unless she has a reason to be....has he done anything to make her this way..otherwise...RUN.

Re: opinions...

Have a talk with her first to see what the problem is. Not necessarily because he wants to make things work but it helps to try and understand the other's side.

What he needs to do is dump her...you dont disrespect each other's parents...ever.