need to know for the sake of knowledge

[ramesha]

Re: need to know for the sake of knowledge

@diwana

You were not truthful when you said you could not answer my simple questions. Interesting.

So here I made black and red colors.

First: By reading your red part it is very certain you are NOT even a muslim. You delibeately degrade and insult the prophet SAW and the first woman in Islam Khadija RAA by calling them on first name basis without respect like they were your buddies (Nauz).

I am not even certain what your religion or faith/sect is.

You do seem to have read some of Islamic history.

You also contradicted yourself. You did say how come these ladies be his SAW daughters, if they would, he SAW would not have them marry idolaters. Hence you did blame him SAW for going against Quran.

Second, you are basing your false assumption that despite your statement that others died in short time, they should have been there for the support of their father SAW?

Provide the timeline here oh my most likely ‘non-muslim historian’ disguising as shia muslim!

If you stop to speed read then you will see that this was an article by Syed Ali Rizvi and not my own writing. I do not believe Prophet (saww) that these ladies were the daughters of Prophet (saww). Try and contribute to the questions I have asked rather than passing judgements on me.

You know, you based your whole argument on claiming these ladies were not his SAW daughters since he SAW allowed them to be married to polytheists. Blaming the prophet SAW for their marriage to polytheists.

I am questioning the popular Shia-Sunni view on these ladies. How could 4 children be born within a space of 10 years and get married. Something is amiss. I am happy to say that my knowledge is very limited but I guess I should not expect a answer here.

But when pointed out, you run away saying because they were married to polytheists, the prophet SAW could not have done that.

Flip-flopping to extreme is obvious.

lost in translation!