need to know for the sake of knowledge

[ramesha]

Re: need to know for the sake of knowledge

@diwana

I am not sure why you did not get the questions right.

I take it you believe the Prophet SAW knowingly gave these women to polytheists. It does not matter if they were biological daughters or not he SAW would not do that. Correct me on this one. He saw would not go against Quran.

I can not answer your questions because they do not apply to me. I am inclined to the view that these ladies were daughters of the sister of Khadija (as). Prophet (saww) was not the guardian, let alone the father, of these ladies!

Allahu Aalam.

Wasalam