[QUOTE]
See how he is unable to comprehend a simple urdu text that a 8th grader can understand fully. Here is what Mr. crankthatskunk displayed in his article
[/QUOTE]
Mr. KCChugtai,
There is absolutely no problem with my comprehension of Urdu text or language. I can read, write, speak, Urdu, Arabic and Persian all three languages, with the grace of Allah SWT.
I had a long discussion with one of the so called Qadianis on another forum. He never ever provided proofs for the credibility of the Mirza on other articles; like every other Qadiani, they always go quite and never attempt to defend Mirza. Says all about their “true Islam”.
But he like you thought it would be easy to talk about this article exactly like you are trying now. The result was devastating for him. You can try too, nobody is stopping you. What I write I can defend without any questions or doubts.
The cutting I produced in my article was from your authentic sources too. So if you produce same material from another book, does not mean anything at all. The material is the same with same contents.
What is your objection? Spell it out, for me to respond.
Another one of you have left two messages on this article, I saw them yesterday, I approve them to be shown on the Web log. I will respond to them in due course, Inshallah.
[QUOTE]
So doors are closed on new prophets but not on prophethood [direct and pure communique between man and Allah] as long as Jesus (as) is alive. When he comes back, he will get direct knowledge and instructions from Allah. It means there is still need of prophethood but new prophet cannot come so an old prophet is kept alive in heavens in order to cater for the needs of later days. I am just thinking out loud.
[/QUOTE]
Ok, let’s test you Mr. KCChugtai,
Tell us one simple thing please; you know when Jesus As was living in Kashmir for almost 90 years according to Mirza.
Was he As a Prophet during that period?
Was he given the Wahi at that time?
Ok, let’s assume if Jews didn’t know where he disappeared, but surely Allah SWT knew isn’t?
*Or you think even Allah SWT didn’t know either (nauzobillah)? *
*Can you provide any evidence of the continuation of the Wahi to ISA AS in these 90 years? *
*Please also tell us, according to Mirza and you Jesus As was alive in Kashmir for 90 years after 3 AD, up until 125 AD, then why there is no mention of this period of his prophet hood in the Holy Quran? *
*Did Allah SWT also forgot (nauzobillah) about his As life in Kashmir and failed to mention a single Word in the Holy Quran for this long period of life? *
*Why Allah SWT never ever decreed anything for this long life of Jesus As in Kashmir, when 3 years of his ministry from the age of 30 to 33 are mentioned in details in the Holy Quran, including his As birth and his As childhood? *
*Why Prophet SAW never uttered a word about this period of life of Jesus As when according to Quranic verse 3:61 he SAW was given the full knowledge about Isa AS by Allah SWT? *
You gave this advice to Mr. Popat that I am interested in the life in Kashmir; perhaps you can shed some light on these questions. These would have been my next sets of questions to Mr. Popat while he search for authentic hadiths which show categorical and unequivocal statements of Prophet SAW for the death of ISA As.
You can solve this mystery for us. I challenge you. Mirza is busted from every angle, I can assure you this, none of you could ever win any arguments from me on the writings of Mirza, cast iron guarantee.