My baby's 1st b-day

[Sehrysh]

Re: My baby’s 1st b-day

@Le_Pakistan

I might have missed it, but where did she state that he does it to discipline the baby?

Now I am sure OP will come back saying that that is exactly what he does, hitting her to discipline her.

Um, here:

@Chameli420

In urdu I would have said ke wo mere baby ko thapki maarte hai.

not thappar but thapki…aur wo bhi ghusse me baat karte hue

Does it make you happy to see that she had previously mentioned it and isn’t just making it up to justify her anger at her FIL’s actions?

You seem to want to prove that the FIL’s actions are okay and that it’s all in jest and therefore should be acceptable. It’s not. Our elders are capable of making mistakes and we have a right to tell them what we will or will not accept for our children.