Re: Mutawatir Ahadith superceding Holy Quran's Ayats
I would beieve any hadeeth which would not directly contradict Quranic verse and 'common sense'. For example people in this forum have quoted some 'hadeeth' that camel urine was prescribed by the prophet SAW allegedly. They also stated that some religious scholar allegedly consumed camel urine in 20th century. I absolutely disagree with that and for me there is hadeeth which say leave anything which makes you feel 'karahiat.
Even though any life saving remedy can be consumed regardless of what it is but we have absolutely no scientific or historic information that camel urine could make someone save from dying. So to me at this point this so called hadeeth has no value and makes no difference on my Islamic belief.
Did you do any research before calling this hadith "so-called?
Have you heard the hadith that says there is cure in honey and surah fatiha for every disease except death. Then how can you think that camel urine can cure you from dying. There is cure in camel urine for some diseases and it has been proved medically.
All I know is that we cannot declare a hadith fabricated without looking at its chain of narrations, opinion of the Scholars of four schools of thought, may be scientifically or historically proved and then by using common sense.
your feeling of ' karahiyat ' from drinking urine camel doesn't make the hadith fabricated or so called. Only If you have looked at the whole hadith and then the opinion of four schools of thought then you know that meaning of this Hadith is that if a person needs to consume an impure and impermissible(like alcohol) substance as a cure for an illness, and no other reasonable alternative is available, then it is permissible. In all other circumstances, camel urine is prohibited.
Which post of mine makes you think like that? Please explain.
I do not want to lower the level of hadeeth so one stops believing on it altogether but I disagree that hadesth are in any way considered 'revelations'.
These are collection of narrated accounts of the Prophet SAW life and his words/actions and surroundings etc. Some authentic some not. Many are consistent with each other but some are contradictory. But none are revelations.