Re: Mutawatir Ahadith superceding Holy Quran's Ayats
In many cases the prophet Muhammad (SAW) would ask his companions questions regarding the meaning of certain ayaat or certain signs, at least they had the decency to say, "Allah (SWT) and His Rusool (SAW) know best", but now we get a translation and think we understand it and then when we hear a hadith that goes against it in our minds then we reject the hadith, but I don't know why we should be doing that?
Because we don't have the luxury of having the Prophet (saw) speak to us and explain the Quran if we have a question. We only have written versions of hadith and Quran. Tell me if Quran and hadith are on exactly the same level, when did Allah (swt) not say that hadith are complete and can never be changed. Why was this only said about the Quran?
And once again why is there no concept of weak ayats or strong ayats but there is such a concept in hadiths? If they were written exactly at the same time, why is this the case? Sorry, this does not pass the logic test and we are allowed to use are brains. If you are comfortable in rejecting a Quranic ayat in favour of a haidth, then that is between you and Allah. I am not ready to do that.