Mutah [temporary marriage] -- Social and cultural perspective

Re: Mutah [temporary marriage] in the time of Amir ul Momineen Ali ibn Abi Talib

Shia and sunni have different interpretations at various junctions in Islam.

Both have done good and bad job in laying down rules. For instance Mainstream sunni Scholars have done pathetic job by messing up the perfect procedure of Talaq layed down in Quran. On the other hand Shia scholars have done a good job by making divorce procedure according to quranic injunctions. :k:
But regarding mutah, I think they (shia scholars ) should have pondered more. They have left many loop holes :nook:

Now comming back to the topic.

I think we need to evaluate pro and cons of mutah in todays world and society, rather then digging centuries old cultures.

Today’s youth face many challenges

  1. Long years of study
  2. Raging hormone level, emotions of love desire for sex getting out of control in teenage and in early 20s
  3. Peer presure of being in relationship
  4. society presure of buiding a career

Now, the common answer of these problems by an avg practising muslim would be abstinence, have faith, trust and fear God ..so on and so forth.

But you know and I know and evey young person knows that it is difficult. In some cases very difficult.

Now living in western society we all know that getting married is difficult and costly. So what is the more natural solution of this problem due to which many young muslim resort to un-islamic means of fullfilling their desires.

Now I think Mut’ah is a way out for young people who want to try out combined living arrangement and companionship/ relationship during college/university days. Thus gaining hands on experience on relationship. Finding out Aatey Daal ka bhao and fulfiling their desire through proper channel.

It would be interesting to know Shia muslim girl’s perspective for this arrangement in todays world.

2 Likes