Re: Mutah [temporary marriage] in the time of Amir ul Momineen Ali ibn Abi Talib
okay so ibn abbas[ra] and jabir b abdullah [ra] did deem Mutah halal even after Umar[ra] 's time ?
Is there a incident where Imam Ali[as] permitted Mutah in his caliphate and people opposed his decision?
brother BOYNICE from your early post it seems that Ali[as] did not do thing that will turn people against him or would contradict the example of first 2 caliphs ....but Ali[as] repeatedly said that he will only follow Quran and sunnah and not the seerah of shaykhan [where it contradicted the sunnah & Quran] infact thats the reason he gave to abdurrehman b auf [ra] when he offered him the caliphate on the condition that he follows the shaykhan ....so why wud Ali[as] later not keep his word ?
secondly Ali[as] did infact do things which were not in accordance with the example of the earlier caliphs , that is one of the reason why the khawarij turned against him ..