Re: Mumtaz Qadri hanged
The conflicts of 3 talaq, 20 rakat of taraveeh, mutaah are few examples where what happened in prophet’s life vs what Umar ordered in his khilafhat clashes with each other, but as doppelganger mentioned, deobandis could die to show that umar was right. If that is not thinking that he was infallible then what else?
In fact the only recorded and authentic daleel that scholars give in support of killing of blasphemous being justified is when Hazrat Umar chopped the head of a Muslim who questioned the judgment of prophet in a dispute against a Jew. Umar did it out of his known uncontrollable anger, and we turned it into a shariah law