Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

KABUL: Taliban supreme leader Mullah Mohammad Omar on Sunday hailed the release of five senior insurgents in exchange for US soldier Bowe Bergdahl as a “big victory”.

“I extend my heartfelt congratulations to the entire Afghan Muslim nation, all the mujahideen and to the families and relatives of the prisoners for this big victory regarding the release of five Taliban leaders from Guantanamo prison,” he said in a rare statement.

“I thank the government of Qatar, especially its emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad (Al Thani), who made sincere efforts for release of these leaders and for their mediation and for hosting them,” he added.

US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel on Sunday expressed hope that the release of Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl would lead to direct US talks with the Taliban. In an interview with NBC’s “Meet the Press,” Hagel noted that the United States had engaged in talks with the Taliban before, until they were broken off in 2012.


Is it the first time such a swap has taken place?

From the reaction of the defence minister, it seems the US was more interested in restarting the talks than getting its sergeant back.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

victory?

The US wanted their soldier back. They got him. They're the victors.
Not these jahil molvi's still living in the stone age, pretending to be the leaders of islam.

Utter nonsense @ so-called victory. What a dumb man.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

:mirch:

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

is the Amir of Qatar a Taliban sympathizer?

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

Giving a useless american ( the reasons for his disappearence vary , one source say he just walked out/others say that he was drunk) against 5 of top men is an achievment. It must have been difficult/burden to keep that american alive for that long, move with him from one hideout to another must have been tough task.

Plus dont rule out possibility of this soldier working as sleeper cell for taliban and may start working on taliban agenda after some months of monitoring on him is ended.( There were rumours of him converting to islam which taliban immediatly denied).

Let see from their acocunts how the treatment of prisinors from both side differ.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

Is there a way to verify that statement by Mulla Omar ... ???

Would the US really give up 5 Taliban leaders?

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

As I said earlier, US is desperately exploring options to restart dialogue with Taliban. So Washington might have seen it as an opportunity to engage the enemy and bring it back to the negotiating table.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

What for?

Might it be something to do with a loss of friendship with Karzai?

Why are the US so desperate? History should have taught us a few things ...

Anyhow ... I still can't see in my perception of "Mulla Omar" admitting to the whole world that the released people from GitMo are Taliban generals - that would be a strategically unwise thing to admit.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

lets see if any headway in talks is possible after this, I read somewhere that Pakistan also played a role in this.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

It is either that Taliban were able to trick Americans to release their leaders in exchange for one treasonous soldier, or the Americans were willing to release five high ranking Talibani leaders as ransom for one lowly ranked soldier. Either way, it does not appear a great victory. Were they able to invade gitmo and get their top leaders freed?

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

As far as victory is concerned that is given by Allah (SWT) ... Imprisoned or freed the true victory is with the believers ... But this statement is one of numbers ... 5 for the price of 1 ...

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

I'd say its a win-win for both. US freed up those leaders but they want this mess to be settled either way. And they got their soldier back alive for which they could do anything. Only time will tell who really is a victor.
The only ugly face of this transaction is that now taliban will be intensify abductions as they know it works pretty good.

Meanwhile in US, republicans are excruciating the govt for dealing with Talibans this way.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

Like SID_NY said it is a win-win, but for taliban it is a bigger win than it is for US ( read obama administration ). Taliban got 5 of their top leaders, made a statement that they can go through a deal, made US negotiate and negotiate with them and stuck it to Karzai. US got their soldier home ( he might end up in jail eventually as a deserter ) and reduced the number of prisoners in gitmo by 5. Needless to say republicans will have a fit, coz mid-term elections are around the corner. But soon McCain the maverick, will change his tune and start supporting this move. So it wont have much of an effect on the elections. Wonder what Rush it talking about today?

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

**

Pak played ‘key role’ in US-Taliban prisoner deal ******

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan may not have been directly part of the prisoner swap deal between the Afghan Taliban and the United States but it quietly persuaded the two sides into breaking the deadlock, it was learnt.

A senior security official familiar with the development disclosed that Pakistan helped the two sides establish initial contacts that eventually paved the way for the release of US Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl in exchange for five Afghan detainees from Guantanamo Bay detention centre.

“We were not part of the final deal but we played our part,” said the official, who asked to remain anonymous because he was not authorised to talk to the media.

It was believed that Pakistan had facilitated certain Afghan Taliban commanders who travelled to Doha for crucial negotiations with the US to broker a deal on the exchange of prisoners. The development, the official said, could prove to be a significant “confidence building measure” between the two sides.

The Afghan Taliban had refused to enter into peace talks with the US until the latter released the group’s prisoners from Guantanamo Bay.

Talks on the prisoners release broke down several times, but the deal was finally brokered after Pakistan cautioned both sides through behind the scene contacts that further delay may diminish chances of a peace agreement.

Official sources revealed that US Secretary of State John Kerry telephoned Pakistan’s Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif last Thursday and informed him about the deal with the Afghan Taliban.

Pakistan is considered pivotal for any peace deal in Afghanistan because of its security establishment’s historic ties with the Taliban and other insurgent groups.

When contacted, a foreign ministry official was quick to clarify that Pakistan’s role would only be that of a “facilitator.”

“We will welcome any step that would lead to long term peace and stability in Afghanistan,” the official added.

Pakistan is officially pursuing a cautious approach as publicly it does not want to be seen playing a central role in the Afghan peace talks due to its likely negative fallout.

Officials now hope that the breakthrough in prisoners exchange may lead to more ‘sustained and direct talks’ between the US and the Afghan Taliban.

They said Pakistan had been pushing all “stakeholders” for months to move on and start “meaningful” negotiations.

Source: is.gd/7bOlB2

Perhaps this is the reason why Karzai is fuming at the development. The more he wants to keep Pakistan at bay, they more Pakistan seems crucial to everything related to Afghanistan.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

Who was bigger enemy of america, these taliban or Afia siddique? If pakistan was that "concerned" with getting a deal between the 2 it must be against some khairat of dollars to get it done. Why couldnt pakistani could do a similar deal for afia swapping her for raymond or the other fbi terrorist.

I dont think pakistan can play a big role for afghan taliban now, they may use us but will never consider us as friends, it is lost war for us in afghanistan. Taliban dont even accept responsibility of the attacks pakistan supported groups do on indian interest in afghanistan, (which is against protocols there as taliban accept every thing done by affiliated groups-AQ-etc) .Pakistani should stop making themselves fools,hakim ullah killed col imam in cold blood still mulla umer praised hakim ullah mehsud, i think our double game policy is known to every one.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

This quote by German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel seems rather appropriate: "What experience and history teach is this — that nations and governments have never learned anything from history, or acted upon any lessons they might have drawn from it."

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

I would agree with you. If Pakistan still has so much influence on Afghan Taliban, how come Mullah Umar played a big role in appointing Mullah Radio as TTP head and how come Islamabad cannot use Afghan Taliban for uprooting Mullah Radio from Kunar province?

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

This is just posturing. I don’t think pakistan has any influence with either of the parties. Things are changing in Afghanistan. If the president elect in this month’s run-off aligns himself with Karzai about US troops, US will quickly strike a deal with Taliban and drop Karzai/president-elect. This Bargdahl deal was a prelude to what is possible, if US troops are not allowed to stay in Afghanistan.

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

WoW! Amreeka does not deal with terrorist but wait these are good terrorist very good... :)

Re: Mullah Omar says prisoner swap “big victory”

In politics, there are no permanent friends or enemies.