Re: Muharram Starts!!! Some Important Questions to Ask (Exclusive)
[quote]
Read about shairi in Quran. Quran main shairi say mana farmaya gia hai Jaisa kay main nain samjha hai. Us shairi say jis main ghalat biyani say kaam liaa jaay.
[/quote]
Please avoid extrapolating from the Quran. Quran does NOT forbid poetry. It DOES forbid 'ghalat biyani'. Dont extrapolate and join the two!! There are already enough lies and misquotes on the web for you to now start paraphrasing the Quran!!!
As for poetry
[quote]
Instead of Reading Naat or Nohas why don't we read quran or Sunnah at that time. Or even our Qiza namaz.
[/quote]
Reading naats and nohas does not preclude reading the quran or sunnah. According to Imam al-Ghazali in the Ihya' 'Ulum al-Deen and Imam Yusuf ibn Ismail an-Nabahaani in Anwaaru'l Muhammadiyyah when the prophet pbuh and hf entered madina after the hijrat; he was eulogized by poetry.
Hassaan bin Thabit used to recite poetry in praise of the Prophet pbuh & hf or to respond to the Kuffar. And he was encouraged by the Prophet pbuh&hf. (according to Bukhari)
There are many more examples of poetry in Islam. So Please lets not all become mullahs and start passing fatwas without research. And above all; lets not extrapolate the Quran!
[quote]
Kia Kaheen Quran main likha hai kay bargahon pay hazri deni chahyay. Again wasting of Time.
[/quote]
:) with all due respect; its not as simplistic as that. Quran ke saath eik adad nabi bhi bheja gaya tha. We should consider him and what he said before getting trigger happy with our fatwas.