Its a Utopia kind thread.
In intend to help some members see beyond their political affiliation based on their ethnicity.
So
1-What would have Quaid-y-azam have thought about altaf?
2-What would Qaid have said about his statements “pakistan is a biggest blunder”
No answer needed.
Shouldn’t good be “just good” like quaid.
and bad should be “just bad” like altaf.
What ethnicity has to do with it?
PS: Don’t ban me.
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
I think the Qaid would be worried about the parties actually in power, that always have been in power. Qaid would be worried about the extremist sunni elements dominating pakistan's government/legal system. Qaid would be worried about most of the people not paying tax (including many peoples parents here - who have proudly stated that its no big deal to pay tax in pakistan). Qaid would be worried about the economy in general. Qaid would be worried about the poverty level. Qaid would also worry about mr altaf in general...but to a much much lesser degree.
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
I think the Qaid would be worried about the parties actually in power, that always have been in power. Qaid would be worried about the extremist sunni elements dominating pakistan's government/legal system. Qaid would be worried about most of the people not paying tax (including many peoples parents here - who have proudly stated that its no big deal to pay tax in pakistan). Qaid would be worried about the economy in general. Qaid would be worried about the poverty level. Qaid would also worry about mr altaf in general...but to a much much lesser degree.
wow you really need to know little more about him.
Couldn't agree with you more.
But purpose of this thread is to show ethnicity is not a just base to support some ones action. Wont you say so??
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
Are you implying Jinnah was a 'Mohajir'?
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
Well by my definition all muhajir are nothing but pakistanis.
If you re read my thread it pnly for the people who have their political affiliations based on their ethnicity(very few)
And yes by their definition Qaid fits the same category as MQM leadership. (ethnically!!!!!!!!!!)
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
KA, Jinnah was born in Karachi, and according to many credible sources, his ancestors were Hindu Rajputs from Sahiwal near Multan.
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
whattttttt
my,cousins are so dumb, they told me he migrated.
lol
let me change the title.
Re: Muhajir’s take on another muhajir’s actions.
Another reliable source makes him Gujrati… Are Rajput Gujrati?
My parents are from Jay pur, Am I Rajput?
Quaid’s father, Jinnah Poonja, was a Parsi as per another reliable source…
Jinnah migrated from one religion to other. He was a muhaajir :halo:
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
dude half of panjab migrated from across the border.
they don't call them self muhajir
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
dude more than half of people or perhaps more now, identifying themselves as muhaajir never migrated.. they were born in Urban Sindh and are living in urban sindh....
Re: Muhajir’s take on another muhajir’s actions.
heeeeennnnnnnnn:konfused:
why would they do that ?
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
Things that make you go hmmmmm :)
I do not know sir... even some of my friends in Karachi identify them as Muhaajir .... it has to do with the alliance with MQM... and therefore, Jinnah is conisdered a muhaajir in their circles as he was also born in Karachi....
errrrr what?
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
I wonder who would they vote for if Qaid was in election against altaf.
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
Quaid was very charismatic . I am sure if Quaid was alive Pakistan , Pakistan would have a different face. There would be no ethnic identity , everybody would be Pakistani.
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
^I know.
ppl say india this india that.
I say If Quaid had lived for another 20 years, we would be stronger than any European nation.
Re: Muhajir’s take on another muhajir’s actions.
If QUAID (Quaid-e-azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, just in case some1 fail to relate word QUAID with him and take it as a title for Altaf) had lived another 20 years, there would be no MQM or Altaf. 
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
Altaf Bhai is Quiad-e-Tahrik, though many refer to him as the Quiad-e-Fisaad.
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
wow you really need to know little more about him. Couldn't agree with you more.
But purpose of this thread is to show ethnicity is not a just base to support some ones action. Wont you say so??
Frankly, its obvious that Pakistan has bigger problems then trying to keep track of some chubby guy's expenses. Qaid would be worried about the things I mentioned. Ideally, once those things are fixed, it would take care of corruption and choors like mr nawaz, mr zardari and ofcourse mr hussien.
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
^So I understand Mr. Hussain is anti Quaid ? and corrupt ?
Re: Muhajir's take on another muhajir's actions.
Quaid-e-azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah was Agakhani from Gujrat and didn't convert to Islam. As far as I remember he died as Agakhani (WRONG AQEEDA).
May Allah have mercy on this Soul.