Re: Mohammed the man vs Mohammed the prophet.
Of course it isn't. If I belonged to a monolithic group of over a billion people that prided itself on following the perfect path laid out by God I don't think I would want to hear that it has been practiced the wrong way for centuries either. It doesn't mean those non-Muslims are wrong. They (we) can look at it objectively as opposed to being indoctrinated from an early age to the wrong interpretation.
Anc why would it have to be only non-muslims that can look at this objectively? There are some but as I am realizing, a small minority