SO if areas of Karachi were inhabited by Sindhis, how does it prove that Karachi is not part of Sindh?
There seems some confusion. I think we all are on same footing that Karachi is part of Sindh since centuries even before the arrival of British troops / East India company. Many historians say that famous city of Deebal during Arab conquest of Sindh in 8th century is either Karachi or was near Karachi. When due to this Deebal (Karachi), Sindh was called 'Bab ul Islam' since more than a Millennium, how can one argue that Karachi is not part of Sindh.
There seems some confusion. I think we all are on same footing that Karachi is part of Sindh since centuries even before the arrival of British troops / East India company. Many historians say that famous city of Deebal during Arab conquest of Sindh in 8th century is either Karachi or was near Karachi. When due to this Deebal (Karachi), Sindh was called 'Bab ul Islam' since more than a Millennium, how can one argue that Karachi is not part of Sindh.
Exactly what I was saying mate. As I said, you may have misunderstood my post. I was replying to TLK when he asked how Karachi was a part of Sindh :)
TLK said:
[QUOTE]
Sindhis provided them new home? Really? Karachi was part of sindh??? hmmm
[/QUOTE]
His reasoning being that Karachi was settled by Makrani and Balochi tribes. In the same way, New York was settled by Britishers (Correct me if I'm wrong, but anyways, you get the idea)
^ sure, it was not urdu speaking journalist but Pashto speaking.
Never at any moment in this mayhem, the reporter in video said that an urdu speaking was beaten up. You cooked up this by yourself to spread ethinic hatred. Being a responsible person of this forum please do not spread any further hatred among people. Thanks.
Exactly what I was saying mate. As I said, you may have misunderstood my post. I was replying to TLK when he asked how Karachi was a part of Sindh :)
TLK said:
His reasoning being that Karachi was settled by Makrani and Balochi tribes. In the same way, New York was settled by Britishers (Correct me if I'm wrong, but anyways, you get the idea)
Agreed. I already responded about TLK post for Baloch and Makranis in my post no. 31. One should promote tolerance and harmony instead of discouraging a community by not acknowledging their due contribution.
Kuchh to Khuda ka khauf hona chahiay.
Kahan aik aam mammoli suasatdan
Aur Kahan hazron Masoom Musalman Pakistanion ka raciest Qatil
Aik nam mahad Sahafi kay dant ki boht fikr hay aur meray piaray
Karachi kay hazron begunah logon ka khoon e nahaq jo pichhlay 25 sal say mussalsal beh raha hay Us ki parwah naheen,
Never at any moment in this mayhem, the reporter in video said that an urdu speaking was beaten up. You cooked up this by yourself to spread ethinic hatred. Being a responsible person of this forum please do not spread any further hatred among people. Thanks.
Kuchh to Khuda ka khauf hona chahiay.
Kahan aik aam mammoli suasatdan
Aur Kahan hazron Masoom Musalman Pakistanion ka raciest Qatil
Aik nam mahad Sahafi kay dant ki boht fikr hay aur meray piaray
Karachi kay hazron begunah logon ka khoon e nahaq jo pichhlay 25 sal say mussalsal beh raha hay Us ki parwah naheen,
They will not stop. Every where in Politics, mudslinging occurs but not to the level of creating differences among people based on ethniciities, language and birth origin.
In Pakistan unfortunately those elements are discussed which bring nothing positive on the table to improve general condition of common people. Rather it makes lives difficult for everyone when politicians ‘fight’ among themselves.
To stop something first the act needs to be pointed out and then be proven wrong. That is what I tried.
This terrorist supporter Lucman should present an evidence of his allegation.
Yara , ek tu , who ever doesnt agree with your POV is either a mqm wala or her supporter :)
Kuchh to Khuda ka khauf hona chahiay.
Kahan aik aam mammoli suasatdan
Aur Kahan hazron Masoom Musalman Pakistanion ka raciest Qatil
Aik nam mahad Sahafi kay dant ki boht fikr hay aur meray piaray
Karachi kay hazron begunah logon ka khoon e nahaq jo pichhlay 25 sal say mussalsal beh raha hay Us ki parwah naheen,
Yar Ap , phelay tu ek baat samj lain ... Koi qaTil choTa bara nahii hota , ek qatal ki saza bi PhaNsii hai or 50 ki bi ...
just because People are not aware of ZM 's crimes , it doesnt make him a saint ... ask any one from his constituency , and he will tell you the reality of this goon .. how he had been supporting Dakaits of sindh ...
dont know how long more we face that BadDuwa called name PPP on Pakistan.
Not for very long - as neither PPP have people nor it is a party any more :)
I said earlier in this thread that all parties are equally involved in Karachi violence. With this picture, I was just trying to show that Mirza is not a saint, as some people think he is.
Also, the recent wave of violence shows that the PPP (and Mirza) are rather more connected with the Lyari gangs than the MQM.
Sindhi and Baloch tribes!!! Very same people Sindhi and Baloch against whom MQM has unleashed reign of terror. Secondly, if you feel that urdu speakers owe nothing to Sindhis or Baloch then no one in Pakistan owes anything to them. Then drop the whole notion of Baniyaan-e-Pakistan thing, bcoz Pakistan came into being due to votes of people living in Pakistan prior to partition. If these peopel had not voted for partition then votes in UP and CP would not have mattered at all.
MQM had no fights with Baloch, ever. I am not sure how this new thing started and by whom. If anything, MQM was and is the biggest supporter of Baluchistan nationalist movement and is always very vocal about it.
About owning anything to anyone, we all owe very much to everyone else.