KcChugtai
Ahhhhh, this is more like it, now you are on the path of heresies, In the foot steps of Mirza, the place where I wanted to take you.
This is the point raised by three of you now, d.tox.ed, Popat and you. I am going to write a follow up of my article and answer the fallacies of your defense. You simply can not clear Mirza from his lies and attacks on Prophet Isa As of the Holy Quran. Wait for this article to appear which will deal with the common excuses used by the followers.
You are still stuck with the dilemma how to prove that Mirza didn’t attack the Prophet ISA As of the Holy Quran. I have quoted his undeniable writings, where he attacked ISA AS. By quoting and insisting that he wrote otherwise too, you are just destroying the credibility of Mirza. But you guys do not understand the meaning of credibility.
Any how, you said;
Is this your assertion; like Mirza that Allah SWT called Isa As “soul from us” after his As birth, to dispel the rumors and allegations leveled by the Jews against Mariam As and H Isa As?
Secondly, in the same quotation by Mirza, Mirza writes Allah SWT used similar words for H Adam As, he quoted from Verse 15:29 “breathed into him of My spirit”
Could you please tell me, what were the allegations against Adam AS that these Words were used by Almighty Allah SWT?
Thank you.
The hadith you quoted is self explanatory; Prophet Muhammad SAW is trying to teach the Muslims importance of “ Haququl Abad”. You Qadianis are very keen on using the term “Allegorical”. But when you find something which is really Allegorical then you shift and start using the literal meaning of it.
Did you pay attention to what I have written in my article? I wrote Mirza said it is allegorical. On Hadith I only wrote, he failed to provide the reference, and said what a wonderful analogy used by Mirza.
You are missing one thing very crucial here, the point I made subtly in my article, which probably you missed completely. I knew the hadith; which is allegorical, this Mirza has admitted in the quotation. But what Mirza produced, according to his claims are the Words of God (nauzobillah). Exactly like the quotations I provide from the book of Genesis; which according to the claims by the Jews and the Christians is Word of God.
Prophet Muhammad SAW didn’t claim it as Word of Allah SWT; he SAW only was pointing to the followers importance of “Haquuq-ul-Abad” by using allegorical words, if this Hadith is actual words of Prophet SAW. This can not be said with certainty.
Did you get the point now?
But the questions I asked; you are trying to avoid them. I asked you questions on the second issue, i.e. Allah SWT visiting the earth (nauzobillah). Please answer the questions.
My full answer on Qadianis excuses is on its way, in my new article. I already warned you guys, not to destroy the credibility of Mirza completely.