Re: Miracles of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
U seems to have only the copy paste knowledge then.
And if have u read the foot notes about the ahadith Ibn-e-Kathis mentioned in very same tafseer of aya? did u ever care to read them for understanding? if yes then my question regarding chain of narrators will be valid for u. but if not ( which is more likely to be the story) then u have no idea what iam talking about. because answer of my question was in my reply, which i have given u above, u either missed it or failed to understand. so again i must say. please do not paste the stuff u have not understood fully.
and my advice to u is, if u can stop wasting time in only copy pasting a start reading something worth reading then u can be more beneficial to ur family and relatives ( but i think u will take my advice as a word of Jahil< thats what u called me right> or may be even worst)
so go and read preface of the book and then we will talk about ahadith
So all of ahadith who talk about miracles are fabricated?
And how many references have you given in your posts?
Re: Miracles of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
So all of ahadith who talk about miracles are fabricated?
And how many references have you given in your posts?
what a petty remark is this? u assume something and then ur imagination make that reality? have u red my posts please go and read them u will find the ref. there in... and still if u cannot find them ( which is most likely the case is) consult someone who can help.
hereonwards, i will not reply u in this thread if u keep posting non-sense.
Re: Miracles of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
what a petty remark is this? u assume something and then ur imagination make that reality? have u red my posts please go and read them u will find the ref. there in... and still if u cannot find them ( which is most likely the case is) consult someone who can help.
hereonwards, i will not reply u in this thread if u keep posting non-sense.
Ok all the Ahadith and ayahs which talk about miracles are "non-sense" according to you.
You just want to deny the miracles of Prophet Muhammad(SAW).
Re: Miracles of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
Now at this point,
the question rises! does the personality of Prophet (PBUH) required to be defended or glorified by associating him with some miracles, when He (PBUH) has given a Book, which it self carries a magical effect, and not a single word of the book can be denied nor a single sentence of a book could be re-created despite the many attempts by humans?
Do his credibility requires a extra-scientific explanation? that He was in his lifetime was able to do certain things which other cannot?
Are we like jews, for whom Man.o.salwa and Piece of Cloud is required to prove the credibility of Allah and his Prophet (PBUH)?
Or are we so blind that we need the Miracles like Jesus (AS) had? to prove himself as a credible Prophet of Allah All Mighty?
Is this the reason we believe in Islam that Prophet had shown some Miracles? becuase if this the reason then we have to re-check our faith!!!
Re: Miracles of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
Now at this point,
the question rises! does the personality of Prophet (PBUH) required to be defended or glorified by associating him with some miracles, when He (PBUH) has given a Book, which it self carries a magical effect, and not a single word of the book can be denied nor a single sentence of a book could be re-created despite the many attempts by humans?
Do his credibility requires a extra-scientific explanation? that He was in his lifetime was able to do certain things which other cannot?
Are we like jews, for whom Man.o.salwa and Piece of Cloud is required to prove the credibility of Allah and his Prophet (PBUH)?
Or are we so blind that we need the Miracles like Jesus (AS) had? to prove himself as a credible Prophet of Allah All Mighty?
Is this the reason we believe in Islam that Prophet had shown some Miracles? becuase if this the reason then we have to re-check our faith!!!
You are right, we don't need any miracle to believe in Prophet(SAW)'s prophethood, as we have the miracle of Qur'an.
And people are still reverting to islam only by reading or understanding or even listening the Qur'an, but Prophet Muhammad(SAW) did show miracles when people asked him, and miracles like splitting of the moon and Miraj did happen according to the Qur'an and ahadith, so we should not deny them.
Thats my point.