milaad

[aqeel123]

Re: milaad

@Aceones

because the Deen was passed on to us like this, from Muhammad to Sahabah raziallaho anhum, from them to Tabaeen, and Taba Tabaee, rahimohum allah ta’la, and then from them to aima karam and like that… plus, Quran explicitly orders us to follow Muhammad :saw: and “wallazeena ma’a hu” that is people with him, and those are “Sahaba”…

We all should Follow Sahaba and i dont have any porblem with that, But i have a right to ask questions when i quote a posters text…

@Khalil KhaaN FaaKhta

i believe meelaad is a bid’a [innovations] and all bid’a are condemned in Islam. anyone who creats a bid’a or follows it are given ample warnings of harsh punishments [saKht sazaa kii va’eedeN aayii haiN]. Allah had completed the deen for us. Prophet [s.a.w.s] said in his last sermon that the audience be witness that he had fulfilled his obligation and passed on the deen to ummat in it’s entirety and that he had completed his mission. anything added to the deen after that is considered bid’a of extreme nature. meelaad is one of them, qabr parasti is another, extremism is yet another.

May Allah save us from bid’aat and make the deen pure for us [Khaalis deen] and help us walk on the siraat ul mustaqeem…aameen!

u can individually send as much salaam as u wish…do it all day and all thru the night. the problem comes when people do it in congregation and especially when they do it right after the namaaz baa jamaa’at in masaajid, thus making it a part of the namaaz.

Quoting the Text in red and looking at the Logic provided in this post, I am asking… If deen is already complete here and to add anything after that point is biddat… Then we shld all stop here and define everthing that was added After this Point as biddat which includes nomiation of Caliph, Translating Quran, taraweeh, Compiling Quran… And as One of the posters Already Said “defining Biddat” itself comes under biddat !!! According to Logic provided in this post no one has a right to Add or delete anything from Deen after this very sermon …Not even a sahabi then why even considers Sahaba’s era becoz that started after the deen was complete.

@TLK

Hazrat Abu Bakar compiled about 3000 hadees that he later destroyed with the fear that what if he quoted something wrong. Hazrat Abu Hurraira lived with prophet for many years and recorded every hadess (6000 on his credit), plus remember that i used the word of ‘need’ in my deifnition and there was no need to compile hadees in book form during the life of prophet.

Sahaba; because they lived with prophet so if they were the best followers and role models for all of us. If they did not do anything, there is no need for us to do.

BTW, my argument is going to clash with your basic beleif so I am not going to further argue on Caliphs comment of yours but Prophet did appoint Abu Bakr as the next leader of ummat. When he asked Abu Bakr to lead the prayers during his last times, he indicated that Abu Bakr is going to be the next caliph

And here my question was if Sahabas r role model for us then we shld do everything any sahabi did Proudly… i.e Suciding, Running away from Battle… Even Having intention of Killing Prophet s.a.w is Sunnat of sahabi… Fighting Ahley Bait, Declaring War against em its all What the role models did. We need to change Defination of Sahabi or Change our Role Models !