milaad

[Code_Red]

Re: milaad

@TLK

Bhai sahab, zara saa aur homework ker laiatay. Hazrat Umar did not invent 20 rakaat. People used to read 12 rakaat qyamul lail and 8 rakat tahajjud, individually or in small groups. All Hazrat Umar did is that he made it into one jamaat. That is why you see some people still leave after 12 (or sometimes after 8).

Bazurgwaar, Moujzana Guzarish hai ke mujhey is tarha treat na karain jaisay log mulana Zakir Naik Ludhiyaanvi ko kartey hain, india se bahar

Quote my statement in full context which is firmly in place here

@Code_Red

Hazrat Umar(ra) had no authority to amend religion Islam, Period.

He never did this either. He offered an optional practice which he considered better in his personal opinion.

Now you can throw your reply out of window or should I do the honour ?

@TLK

Really!

All those people in this thread who are mocking the argument that Milad is biddat by throwing things like if milad is biidat then Molvi is biddat and toothpaste is biddat and Khilfhat os biddat; fine I am convinced through your sarcasm that Milad is not biddat. With due respect then, please define biddat to me, which act would be biddat then in your knowledgeable opinion.

Sorry to say that I fully wholeheartidly do not agree here.

Here are few examples of biddat common among sunnis folks

Milaad is a biddat. If it is just praise, zikar Darood o Salam then it is ok, otherwise it is not

Traveeh in jamaat (congregation) a biddat. I have explained it in detail. it is ok.

3 Talaq in one sitting is a biddat. This is wide spread among sunnis. This is a criminal offence and a clear blasphemy of holy Quran. Sunni approve this blasphemy because our forefathers did this by mistake.

Any person issuing 3 talaq in one sitting should be put behind bars and should be prosecuted
under section 246 A,B C and should be executed by the orders of court for blasphemy of holy quran in Islamic republic of Pakistan.