Living in USA

[The_Jinx]

Re: Living in USA

@TLK

I will read all your posts.

Now answer one more question.

If I dont agree that USA should do more than just condemning (and when you say that USA should do more then please also tell under which clause of law USA should do that), then does that mean that I dont love Prophet Mohammed as much as others do?

also tell me that if I dont agree that USA should do more, somehow it shows that I am not united with Muslim Ummah?

not an expert in USA laws but freedom of speech is governed by some exceptions in constitution and one of them is “SLANDER”. If you think the movie was not a slander, that’s another point.

for your second point, it shows that you have a difference of opinion at best. There is nothing agaisnt unity there. You and I are united in condemning the movie.

@Sehrysh

I had a VERY interesting conversation with someone about just this idea - is the individual responsible for the sins/crimes of the collective. **Is silence considered ratification or support of the actions of the collective?

**Because if that’s the case, then the entire Muslim ummah would be responsible for the hate crimes of the 9/11 bombers, no?

why? did entire Muslim ummah remain silent on 9/11? Pakistan for one had to suffer the most in aftermath.

It was wrong then, It is wrong now.