light a candle in memory of victims or Ruju' ilal-Allah ?

[P_G]

Re: light a candle in memory of victims or Ruju’ ilal-Allah ?

@kakaballi

I rest my case. I can quote a thousand ahadees out of context and make up anything. This is exactly what Taliban and other extremists do to promote their agenda and this is exactly what anti-Islamic propagandists do to promote theirs. Please paste complete ahadees and with context.

There are ahadess which say things like “go and kill non-muslims”. Taken out of context, they fulfill the propaganda of both extremists and anti-Islamic elements.

I don’t know much about technicalities of the things you mentioned but I know a couple of things…

1. Islam is very much based on common sense.
2. I have a little common sense.

I refuse to believe that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) issued a general prohibition against clapping based on what I read on those ahadees you quoted. I refuse to follow such ‘ulema-e-haq’ which unnecessarily bring complications and divisiveness in the religion to keep their “profession” thriving.

You own avatar is depicting something you claim to be unIslamic. Thank you. I’m out.

or mujhay nahi maloom mainy kon se hadees ko baghir context k paish ker k apne taraf say koi cheez banaayee hai ?

app apne maloomat k ley zara yeh bhi dhoond lejeye ga k woh kon kon say maqmaat thay jahan Nabi slal Allaho alyhi wasalm ya sahab-e- karam nay Clapping ki thee.. jub k yeh ammal us waqt kia jata tha koi ab naye cheez ayjaad nahi hoyee ..or jub app ko yeh cheez kaheen na millay to us per thora sa sooch lejeye ga

baqee main wazahat ker chuke thee k yeh pasandeeda or na pasandeede amaal ki behas hay …jis main sirf tergheeb he de ja sakte hai

bake mere avatar maujhay sirf chaand samjh ata hay …agar koi unislmaic slogan hay to app bata saktay hain ..