Re: lailatul mairaj...
If anyone innovates any matter with our religion, or Prophetic tradtion it will be rejected.
Its a authentic hadith. Its the same above.
Re: lailatul mairaj...
[quote]
the way any muslim follows the religion is his or her own decision.....
[/quote]
SUREEEEEEE! What would you do or say when a "muslim" wants to perform sajda with his ass rather than his head? (Nauzubillah!) Would you still continue to ignore the innovation and ways people have created as ways to worship other than what prophet Mohammad bin Abdullah and God has ordered us to do?
Re: lailatul mairaj...
Br perhaps you do not want to read quran or intetionally do not want to read?
***"Glorified be He who carried His servant at night from Masjid al Haram to Masjid al‑Aqsa, the precincts of which We have blessed so that We may show him of Our Signs. Verily He is the All Hearing, the All‑Seeing. *Surah al‑Isra (Sarah 17 ‑ also known as Bani Isra`il),
have you hear these words in your life **Masjid al Haram to Masjid al‑Aqsa,
**
wassalam
**
Re: lailatul mairaj...
My brother my questions are different. I have read the complete tafsir of this surah. Please go read.
Al Isra, Ibn Katheer, tafsir and only the first verst the explanation if you read it carefully is for 1 hour.
Fact is did Prophet celebrate or not was this a one-off day. You are not able to answer, this question.
Allaah knows the best.
Re: lailatul mairaj...
..
Re: lailatul mairaj...
Our Holy Prophet Muhammad (SAWA) preached through practical demonstration and which the present Muslim world has largely neglected to its own detriment. and what you understand by celebrating? recite quran and tell other about incident of miraj and both are sunnah of our holy prophet(s.a.w)..
Do you know why some so called muslims do not want to discuss this incident? Listen this incident twice thrice and then do some research by consulting your ulemas and you will realise enemies of Khaifa e rashedeen Hazrath Ali(a.s) do not want tell others his position in islam..
any way recite quran and tell others this incident on 27 rajab and both are sunnah.
“And those who disbelieve say: You have not been sent as Prophet. Say (O Muhammad): Allah is sufficient as a witness between me and you and he who has knowledge of the Book.” (13:43)
wasslam
Re: lailatul mairaj...
i really dont want to get into this kind of discussion which makes no sense....
what i said was that if someone wants to recite the holy Quran or say nafal on this particular day then its a personal decision and there is nothhing wrong with it....
but what u came up has nothing to do with it.....infact with due respect what u said does not make any sense.....and makes me wonder why any sane person would want to do that....
all i had asked for was what day is laila tul mairaj.....not that what does the world think about it....
Re: lailatul mairaj...
SMMA59, Dear Br. I find it even more contradicting that you would single out the Surahs you had mentionde earlier to recite on Isra and not read Surah AlIsra.
I think what is being said here is that do not propagate your own routine of religous practice as something that has been prescribed in Islam or as part of the Sunnah. Sure you can recite as much Quran or supplicate as much as you want any day of the year and more on Isra however this is of your own choice and not because we have been commanded to pray something specific on this day. You can commemorate it by praying and recitation but do not propagate it as if it is some commandment or Sunnah practice. Like the last ten days of Ramadan have been specifically mentioned for worshipping. This does not mean that the first twenty days of Ramadan we should not worship however we know there is more reward and advantage of doing the same acts in these last ten days. Or the reward of these last ten days of Ramadan has been multiplied compared to the other days of Ramadan. The day of Isra is important in Islamic history from an eventual perspective but there is nothing that indicates that worshiping or recitation this particular day carries more reward compared to other days of the month of Rajab.
So by attaching a routine of reciting certain Surahs you are inherently stating that if I read some other Surahs from Quran this same day it would not have as much reward as compared to if I had recited the Surahs you mentioned. You are venerating and telling others to beyond your authority and telling others there is more reward in following the routine you have mentioned when you cannot claim to do so or have the authority to do so.
Re: lailatul mairaj...
Don't know why Jaan Leva chose those words, but he is implicitly referring to a concept in Islam which is as follows:
All actions are Halaal until specifically proven Haraam.
All acts of worship are Haraam until specifically proven Halaal.
Re: lailatul mairaj...
SMMA59, I would have expected a reply from you.
Re: lailatul mairaj...
Give them the lailtul qadars, give them the shab-raats, give them the eid milads, give them the 27th of ramadan, give them the 11th date of the month, give them the jumay-raats (thursdays) so they can worship and do eebaada because all other nights are haram on them... give them the "easy" way to heaven. Give them few dead saints and their graves and they will bend backwards to pay respect to them by prostrating to the graves. Yali Madad bhi aur ya allah madad bhi. *Rind ke rind rahey aur musalmani bhi na ghi. *
Lets see WHAT i got pissed at:
[QUOTE]
the** way any muslim** follows the religion is his or her own decision.....
[/QUOTE]
When will this "his way" and "my way" bs stop? Who authorized your way or my way of worship? Who the hell are you or me to say that my way the way I do it or the way you do is good way to follow the religion or worship? There is no YOUR way. It doesn't exist, don't try it. Only way, the valid way is that of Quran and sunnah of the prophet and his sahaba.
When will this stop? When people start doing sajdas "their" way? I only listed the extremes....
Re: lailatul mairaj…
what you expect from me br. here? what to say to those who do not know the meaning of sunnah or do not know what is their exct faith. Br. jaan leva send us link www.Islamicity.com to read and then speak against the matter published there. what to say except that they are confused.
wassalam
Re: lailatul mairaj…
I posted this earlier:
**SMMA59, Dear Br. I find it even more contradicting that you would single out the Surahs you had mentionde earlier to recite on Isra and not read Surah AlIsra.
I think what is being said here is that do not propagate your own routine of religous practice as something that has been prescribed in Islam or as part of the Sunnah. Sure you can recite as much Quran or supplicate as much as you want any day of the year and more on Isra however this is of your own choice and not because we have been commanded to pray something specific on this day. You can commemorate it by praying and recitation but do not propagate it as if it is some commandment or Sunnah practice. Like the last ten days of Ramadan have been specifically mentioned for worshipping. This does not mean that the first twenty days of Ramadan we should not worship however we know there is more reward and advantage of doing the same acts in these last ten days. Or the reward of these last ten days of Ramadan has been multiplied compared to the other days of Ramadan. The day of Isra is important in Islamic history from an eventual perspective but there is nothing that indicates that worshiping or recitation this particular day carries more reward compared to other days of the month of Rajab.
So by attaching a routine of reciting certain Surahs you are inherently stating that if I read some other Surahs from Quran this same day it would not have as much reward as compared to if I had recited the Surahs you mentioned. You are venerating and telling others to beyond your authority and telling others there is more reward in following the routine you have mentioned when you cannot claim to do so or have the authority to do so.**
I expected a reply to this.
Re: lailatul mairaj…
when i said recite sura this this and that on 27 rajab few ignorants strted to discuss about sunnah of holy prophet (s.a.w). It is recomended to recite
** Al Faatih’ah
2) Al Ikhlaas
3) Al Falaq
4) An Naas
5) Al Kaafiroon
6) Al Qadr
on that day but if any member want to recite complete Quran , then it will be considered better act.
nothing belong to my fixed routine. if you accept that day is important in islamic history what wrong in discussing on same date in masjid or inviting people to discuss on it and reciting quran or any specific sura?
wassalam
**
Re: lailatul mairaj…
I think this is what I am trying to figure out. Who recommended to read these Surahs on this particular day. Is this mentioned anywhere in the ahadith or any historical account of this recommendation.
Re: lailatul mairaj...
Scholars select suras according to occasion and choose by meanings. some verse declare tauheed some are warnings ect
But there is no hard and fast rule. It is not written here thjat you can not recite sura e yaseen on that day. so there is no meaning of asking who recommended.
wassalam
Re: lailatul mairaj...
But there is no hard and fast rule. It is not written here thjat you can not recite sura e yaseen on that day. so there is no meaning of asking who recommended.
wassalam
there is a reason for asking, the Prophet salAllahualaihiwasallam used to recite Surah Kafiroon and Surah Ikhlas in the Sunnah salah of Fajr and Maghrib, and also in Witr
so if scholars are picking something randomly to recite on a particular day then they are creating somethin new in religion, right???
they are creating a Sunnah which is not a Sunnah of the Prophet
Re: lailatul mairaj…
I am reading this to mean that the day when the mairaj occured had historical significance and religious significance, but observing the aniversary of this day is not a religious event and has no religious significance.
Re: lailatul mairaj...
I have not said include it is salat. for daily routine there is no restriction and antbody can choose any soora for reciting any day..
why people here make fun of sunnah? You are using internet to learn and discuss islam.
This is not a sunnah and as you started new practice it is biddat also. Any fool can object like this who do not know exctly the meaning of sunnah and where it is applicable.
wassalam
Re: lailatul mairaj…
thats what it seems like to me.
I mean one can read any surah any day, night, its their business, but when it is some sort of organized ritual of specific surahs or specific days/nights then it becomes more .. and I have not seen any answers yet that justify it being more.
its an anniversary of an important event in our history, but aside from that, i hve not read anything that it has any significance for us from a religious perspective.