Kia Islam main Taqleed Zaroori hai ?

[kakaballi]

Obviously this 'far' in red is not that far....lol... No offense but you definitely need a scholar to get at-least the basics of Islam clear in your head.

HaqooqUllah are the first in the list and what you said above is not that.

Again, you are ignoring the 'bit' part. I am sure God wouldn't want us to pray or fast like robots. you can go 'a bit' differently and still be okay. Do you think if I break my fast 10 minutes after sunset I have done something wrong?

V/S

I say my prayers the 'right' way and cheat my customers 'a bit', for me that's not acceptable.

I accept that I have limited knowledge but I atleast know that ignoring haqooq-ul-ibad has brought us where we are and taking care of them has taken the western societies to where they are.

[kakaballi]

Your uncle is a good man. Salat with naipolish is forbidden only because you can't perform wudoo with nailpolish on. You can put the nail polish on after the wudoo and pray....no problems there.

Second, your uncle did what most of us uncles/fathers do. we don't know if our daughters are in a condition to pray or not so it is not proper to force a female to pray... It is best if this is left on daughters or their mothers.

He wouldn't have doubts about me (being a male) in a condition to pray? would he? ;)

And I think I have gone a lot off topic. Apologies.

[TLK]

But I do know that God wouldn't really care about trivial things like your hands being on your bellybutton or chest during salat OR did you break your fast at sunset or 10 minutes after. What HE would care about is whether your heart was in it.

I dont know about breaking the fast example but on the belly button example, I totally agree with you

for unintentionally breaking the fast 10 minutes earlier, we can pray that Allah accepts our fast

if we do it on purpose, without a reason, than I am not sure if Allah would see it as submission cause to me it looks like a rebelliousness.

[PakiAmerican]

Again, you are ignoring the 'bit' part. I am sure God wouldn't want us to pray or fast like robots. you can go 'a bit' differently and still be okay. Do you think if I break my fast 10 minutes after sunset I have done something wrong?

Allah is the most merciful, he will probably forgive most of our 'tooti phooti' Ibadaat but when it is determined and agreed upon to break your fast at a certain time....why be rebalious ?

I accept that I have limited knowledge but I at least know that ignoring haqooq-ul-ibad has brought us where we are and taking care of them has taken the western societies to where they are.

You are right, you are going off topic...

[psyah]

Re: Kia Islam main Taqleed Zaroori hai ?

The trivial matters in faith are what add up to earn little things of good.

Of course God has no need for our worship nor does it reduce anything of God if we do not do big or small things, but it should matter to us. We should strive to do as much as a little thing as perfectly as possible. Each time being conscious of that atoms weight of good.

It may not make sense to us entirely and we often get it wrong saying it does not matter to God. We should rather be telling ourselves that we have only one chance (one life) to get it right ... so at least lets try. If we try to get it right by this and that action then that is a reward, getting it right is two rewards. The ignorant is not the same as the learned and we aught to learn as much as we can push ourselves to acquire.

[diwana]

I just thought of something.

Presenting my thoughts.

An interview with sheep.

There was a man who was able to talk with a sheep.

He interviewed the sheep.

Here is the lowdown on it:

Q: Sheep sahab Kia Haal Hain/

A: Bhain!............ Theek Hoon.

Q: Aap Boltay Bhi Hain?

A: Bhain! ............ Ji Haan. Alhamdo-Lillah.

Q: Aap Ki Khwahish Kia Hai"?

A: Koi Bhi Nahin. Pehlay Thi. Ab Nahin.

Q: Kiyon Bhai Sheep?

A: Meray Malik Ne Kaha Hai Gunah Hota Hai Agar Dunyia Main Kuch Maango. Sab Kuch Baykaar Hai. Bas Aakhrat Hi Main Khush Honga.

Q: Accha? Aap Ka Malik Kaun Hai?

A: Who Bohat Accha **INSAAN **Hai. Us Ko Sab Maaloom Hai.

Main Samajhta Hoon Who Sahih Hai. Aur Main To Bas Aik Sheep Hoon.

Main To Kuch Soch Bi Nahin Sakta.

Aur Kuch Sochoonga Bhi To Kia faida? Mera Malik Phir Bhi Zyada AqalMand Hai.

Q: Acha bhai Sheep yeah bataao tumhee khanay mein kia pasand hay?

A: Mujheay tu woo samnay wali ghaas khana pasand hay magar mera malik mujh say khata hay bus yeah hee ghaas khaao jo wo la kar deta hay.
Baqi Sab Haraam Hai Mujh Par.

Q: Agar tum doosri wali ghass khao gaye tu kia tumhara pait kharab ho ga?

A: Naheen maloom magar mera malak khata hay wo ghass achi nahee hay meray liyee.

Q: Bhai sheep kia tum koi kitab parh sak tay ho?

A: Bolnay Ke Ilaawa Mujhay Parhna Bhi Aata Hai. Pata Nahin Kaise Yeh Hua.

Magar mujhay kuch samajh nahee aata kia parh raha hoon.

Q: Tu phir tum kia kartay hoo?

A: Wohee jo malik kehta hay.

Q: Tumhay kabhee Bhabi Sheep ka khayal aata hay?

A: Kiyun nahee.

Q: Acha tu kabhee miltay ho us say?

A: Jee janab.

Q: Kaisay?

A: Jasay malik kehta hai.

Q: Yeh kia baat hoi?

A: Ab kia tum bahas karoo gaye us baat par jo mera malik, peer-u-murshid, mera Aaqa, Mera walee kehta hay?

Tumhay sharam nahee aati? Mujhay behkatay ho?

Q: Nahee bhai. Mera yeah mutlab nahee tha. Mein sirif yeah pooch raha tha keh koyee aisa kaam bhee hay jo tum khud say kartay ho?

A: Nahee bhai main tu bas aik sheep hoon.

*Ya to tumhay dikhayee nahee day ta ya sumjh nahee aata. *
**Kia tum bhee meri tarha sheep ho??????

**( I thought of a longer version but I think you will enjoy the shorter version better)

[righteous]

@bitter_reality

Taqleeed was prevalent in the blessed era of the Sahaabah (R.A) and the Tabieen (R.A) without objection
Muslims of today follow four main school of thoughts in Fiqh namely :

Hanafi (founded by Abu Hanifa)
Maliki (founded by Malik ibn Anas)
Shafi’i (founded by Muhammad ibn Idris ash-Shafi`i)
Hanbali (founded by Ahmad bin Hanbal

for more information on it please visit BETA138 : Situs Slot Thailand Gacor Hari Ini Slot88 Resmi Terpercaya

How conveniently you have removed a 20% or so of Muslims from Islam who follow the Jafer’i school

[Das_Reich]

Re: Kia Islam main Taqleed Zaroori hai ?

I dont think ahle hadith fit into any of the 4 categories either

there are 7 schools of thought in islam today these 4 plus salafi, jafari, zaydi

[AllahkaBanda]

As-Salamu 'Alaykum

1 - The people are divide in 4 categoriesa) those who are complete mujtahid

b) those who are not complete mujtahid but they can weigh up the evidence and scholars’ opinion and thus choose the most correct one as they have the knowledge

c) those who can’t do the tarjeeh (outwieghing between evidences), it is ONLY PERMISSIBLE for them to follow the opinion of one of the mujtahid or trustworthy scholars, meaning a madhab. However, they must reject the opinion of their imam if it contradicts the Qur’an or Sunnah or they find out that opinion of their imam has not supporting evidence. This category mostly inculdes the students of knowledge

d) the laypeople who can’t do any of the above - they are obliged to ask the people of knowledge, as they Qur’an tells us, it could be your local Imam or Mufti or some Shaykh. People in this category are not allowed to read up books of ahadith or fiqh and come to some sort of conclusion.
2 - the layman has no madhab so we should stop talking about the issue of taqleed and wheter we should follow a schoar or not. We’re simply obliged to ask the trustworthy scholar/mufti for fatwa. If he happens to be a hanafi, for example, it doesn’t mean you’re also a hanafi.

3 - Taqleed - following a madhab is only permissible for people in the above described category # 3. Something doesn’t become obligatory unless it is prescirbed as such in the Qur’an or the Sunnah.

4 - The extreme positions are two: 1) Everyon SHOULD FOLLOW a madhab 2) Everyone SHOULD ABANDON a madhab. Both of them incorrect as it is taking the extreme path. The people of knowledge have relayed and convyed us, allhamdulillah.

Wallahu A’lam

@Das_Reich

there are 7 schools of thought in islam today these 4 plus salafi, jafari, zaydi

brother, when did salafi become a madhab?

[Pagluu]

Re: Kia Islam main Taqleed Zaroori hai ?

Salafis are Wahabis, no?

[AikPakistani]

Yes, but IMO Salafis consider 'Wahabi' a derogatory term.