Khalifa Umar(ra) -- Split from Praying under influence

[hareem01]

@Nussairee

Amazing to c the lengths ppl like Ibn Sadique go to defend Khalifa Umar. E.G. he compares Khalifa sahab’s refusal and clear disobedience of Rasool Akram (s.a.w.w.) (which made the prophet angry and made even Ibne Abbas cry, all according to the great Sahi Bukhari) to Imam Ali’s unwillingness to write a statement which is against fundamental belief of Islam!

-Did the prophet condemn or became angry with Imam Ali ath the hudaybia treaty as he did with Khalifa Umar in the event of thursday? (i think the earlier is what Mr Ibne Sadique may b trying to portray)

-Imam Ali’s action was infact a great one since only the prophet of Allah had the right to address himself as ‘Mohammad Bin Abdullah’ as the whole deen of Allah with its kalima e shadat that we read revolves around the prophet and the Almighty. Hence its only Allah (swt) or his apostle who have to authority to alter/change it. This actually shows the solidness and strength of Imam Ali’s emaan, subhan Allah!

You missed this!

Ahlel Bayt Articles Hadith About the (Non)Incident of the Pen and Paper [A Sunni Perspective]