Khalid bin Waleed controversy [split- Sahaba fan club]

[Code_Red]

Re: Khalid bin Waleed controversy [split- Sahaba fan club]

I agree with Das Reich

*to USR *
so if we can dismiss so ligthly the execution of malik b nuwaira why cant we do the same for all the other more high profiled sahaba …if a sahabi kills a sahabi thats okay if a nonsahabi kills a sahabi thats a big deal …is there regicide in islam?

*Why this act is not a big deal ? *

*Just because Khalid bin Waleed (ra) was in commanding position and was incharge of ruling armed forces. *

*I agree that we are not allowed to marry a woman during her Iddat period, this is clear from Quran and Sunnah and yes Khalid bin Walid RA action conflicts with it however we can only surmise what priorities were taken into consideration by Abu Bakr RA when deciding upon this matter. Sometimes wrong-doings cannot be disciplined when greater interests are at stake. This is something even Rasul Allah SAW demonstrated during his lifetime by never taking Abdullah bin Ubay Salool to task for all the ills he had conjured, it was not in the best interests of Islam at the time so Rasul Allah SAW always took a lenient approach with him *

Sorry to say but are you remotely trying to justify an act of great noble companion of prophet (pbuh) by an example of clear cut hypocrite ? I would rather not do that.

The acts of Abdullah bin ubey were limited to conscpiracy and mischeif. but this act was a brutality and (if we give total benefit of the doubt in case of murder ) still This so called nikah was a clear voilation of quranic injunctions.

On one hand we grew up reading story of Hazrat Umar’'s (ra) exemplary justice where he punished his son till death for consuming liquor on other hand not taking him(khalid bin waleed) to task ?

Although Hazrat Umar dismissed Khalid from the post of Army chief when he was on winning spree but the reason given were different