Karo-Kari

[ravage]

@Maverick_27

whatever… karo kari is an importance but the prostitution and adultery is more henious crime. we need to enforce shariah law .

If you’re going to spend your time arguing that karo kari has a positive impact, that it is close to your ideal shariah punishment etc, please atleast have balls enough to not double talk. You dont merely think that ‘adultery is a more heinous crime’, you dont even think it is a crime, really. So give up the pretence.

beside karo kari has a positive aspect too considering the weakness in our judicial system, lack of integrity in general public and corrupt police. in karo kari the sardars and mir of the tribes gives their verdict that is unlawful as per constitution but the point here is, we can have two opinion about the legality of the system but i have no issue if the case is proven by the reliable witness and opportunity of being heard is provided to the accused (that is generally the case) the concept of karo kari is very close to islamic concept of punishment for adultery.

A more persuasive argument against shariah laws I couldnt make if I tried.

2ndly i doubt the veracity of this report u r refering too and its sound rather illogical. as i have heard that honour killing generally ensue the vendetta resulting in many male deaths in the following years y not to include those deaths in to this. there may be other reason since u have access to ur females thats y they come easily under the knife while the male may have a get a chance to escape from the scene. but the ppl following the tribal tradition do take revenge sooner or later. 3rdly since NGO has to mint the money it always come with the fudged data.

You dont read properly. The numbers I cited were from the Pakistan Senate based on registered cases. Due to the nature of this crime, and the powerlessness of the victim a vast majority of them dont result in cases being registered. This is a conservative figure, there have been figures quoted as high as ten thousand per year. Though that number is more likely to be closer to the truth, I didnt use it because it can be questioned by arguments such as you erroneously made.

on the other hand, unfortunately, police and other law enforcing agencies are not doing much to eradicate the cancer of prostitution rather at time they support this evil.

Great. So perhaps you should start by killing a prostitute, mutilating her body, burying her in an unmarked grave. You think it will have a positive impact on society, please demonstrate the courage of your convictions.

@Maverick_27

i m pujabi and we dont follow this practice. but i think the nature of this tradition is very much close to the concept of rajam (specially in the case of adultery) and we cas take guidance from this practice to make our laws against zina in line with quran and sunnah. current punisment for the adultery as per law is , imprisonement , that is not accordance with the guidelines of shariah.

karo kari is applicable to both sexes, y only female is discussed… ( y no one talk about the 1600 men … as per the discussed report).

Again, bad reading skills. 1600 was the number of women who were killed with no male counterpart (2800-1300). The number should be 1500 though.

So why arent people talking about the 1300 men? Clearly because the killing of women is a much more rampant problem, occuring at more than twice the rate. The murder of anyone is a shame, whether male or female.

where the karo kari is practiced (like interior sindh) have less ratio of extra marital affairs, adultery and prostitution than where it is not practiced like karachi.

Sure, just pull stuff out of your behind, with no attempt to substantiate it, and no possible basis for it.