This is yet another discussion where falsehoods are being propagated in the name of religion. Or perhaps this is based on 5th grade Mutalia Pakistan book that typically mutilates the real history.
Just remember the BASIC facts.
100% of Islamic scholars (of national stature) were AGAINST the formation of Pakistan and all of these Islamic scholars considered Jinnah as Kafir (or at least a Muslim of the lowest level of belief).
So the fact is that
Either
#1 --------all those Islamic scholars were WRONG
Or
#2 ------ Pakistan was never meant to be a theocratic Islamists’ state.
#1 is not true. Because all the big names scholars like Madoodi cannot be wrong. They had done their research and homework to figure out their ANTI-Pakistan position.
Thus #2 must be true.