Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
his logic seems to the acceptable only to thoese who don't have solid knowledge of Quran and ahdees the persons who have even little bit of knowledge of Quran o Hadees can easil reject him because his logic based only on imagination and without solid background and this is the main reason why mainstream scholars have rejected him
Allah created every thing including Insan and Jin. Humans were given full freedom and then have to be accountable to Allah in the akhrat. Only and only creator can decide whom he will forgive and whom he would punish. Allah does not give wisdom (danai) to everyone. And also, only Allah can help to get Hadaet.
If you have red Quran and actually understood it, then you would not say any bad things about Jawed Ahmed Ghamdi. In my view, he is a real Islamic scholar who actually understands the message of the Quran and does not get entangled into incidental examples or things those have no much of the importance or are purely cultural. We are islamists and not a good muslims.
See in World, some Islamists have permitted themselves to carry out the works only Allah is entitled to do. No one has right, specially, muslims, to announce someone kafir or nonislamist. We Islamists still stuck with, hijab, shalwar, burqa, and similar things that cause spliting the hormony of the societies. Instead of contributing to the world in discovering the greatness of Allah and his design of the universe (other nations are doing so) we are stuck to things that have no importance.
I believe, you may want to look Mr Ghamdi's explanations of Quran and issues Ummah is facing currently, in a positive way. He, in my view, is blessing not only for islamists but for other beliefs and kinds. May Allah bless all of us. Amen.