Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
If someone wants to see a debate between Javed Ghamidi and Dr. Israr Ahmad on Islamic state and Jihad, he can download from here: http://tv-almawrid.org/vd/13_islamic_state_01.zip
It is interesting to see that Ghamidi knows alot more about our classical jurisprudence than revivalists like Israr Ahmad and I think people will see alot of catch 22s in arguments of Dr. Israr. From my trivial understanding after watching several sittings of Ghamidi with other scholars, I feel that it is difficult for most contemporary scholars to discuss with Ghamidi on hardcore issues like Jihad, when he has firm grip on Muslim scholarly history and their knowledge.