Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
But I think Usman! you haven't understood the basic difference in Ghamidi and our previous top scholars. The difference is not on the fact that sayings of the prophet should be given the status in religion or not. But real difference is that Ghamidi doesn't follow the opinion of traditional scholars in some fields. For example, Ghamidi never rejected hadith of killing a apostate. But he has an excellent explanation for it, which he has deduced from the over-all structure of Qur'an and if you look at the complete life of the Prophet. Hence, before you will start fighting again, please first try to understand that where is the difference. Because, once the problem will be defined properly, criticism will also be of good quality. :)