Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
Usman! These are all your imaginations that Ghamidi believes that the Prophet never received anyother Divine help other than Qur'an. But for us, what the prophet has left is Qur'an and Sunnah (which is present in Ummah in practice without any flaw just like Qur'an is with us without any flaw). On the contrary Ahadith are collected by individuals and then transmitted to us. Their stature is paramount in understanding the life of prophet. But do you want us to consider something equivalent to Qur'an about which our top Muhaddith has worked and sometimes have disagreed as well. By this you mean, Imam Malik and Imam Bukhari were prophets? They can never make mistake!! Those people who met them were all angels? They could never tell lies about chain of narration. If this is your conclusion, then I think you are not even aware of history of Islam and evolution of Islamic law.
But the real fact is that you are denying sayings of prophet Muhammad yourself and you haven't given any satisfactory explanation for those Ahadith in which Prophet Muhammad says that he is fallible in worldly affairs. You only want to accept those Ahadith which goes along your own understanding of Islam.
And thank you MKF for your valuable comments.