Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
thanx
[quote]
And I think ethics (Ikhlaqiat) is the one about which prophet said that it will be the heaviest on the Judgement day in the scale. You believe it or not, I'd love to listen to a more scholarly criticism of Ghamidi, as I personally believe that what Ghamidi has written is definitely different from our traditionalist understanding of Islam and this should be scruitinized properly. As it can be very dangerous or a great blessing of God on us as a good scholar is definitely a blessing and they are not born everyday.
[/quote]
no one need scholarly criticism to prove Ghamidi wrong
Go and check out the 7 points of proving the sunnah not a sunnah by Ghamdi
from thoes
where are the proves for these
1.that Hazoor PBUH done things without the approval of Allah Almight **
**(proof necessary , if you fail then i will show you that all is by Allah )
2.he had revived them as part of the religion of Abraham (sws) and given them religious sanction
(although every one knows that he was illeterate then how can he study the religion of Abraham SWS and make them islamic )
totally illogical
3.words or acts of the Prophet (sws) will not be called Sunnah
then whose words will be called sunnah
4.prohibition cannot be termed as Sunnah
who declares that, does Allah or Rasool
- Those guidelines of the Prophet (sws) cannot be regarded as Sunnah the nature of which is fully sufficient to show that the Prophet (sws) never wanted to constitute them as Sunnah.
see your exmaple here as well
clearly wants to change what Hazoor PBUH told and want to change nimaz woow
you always said that Ghamidi always give opinion from Quran o Sunnah
then bring prove, but you always run from here