Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi
Has there ever been some one before who has tried to interpret the Deen like Ghamadi is trying to do now?
* *
Welll Ghamdi is mostly follow the path of Aimaan islahi aur Farhi sahaab.Jahaan taak ghamdi ke scholar hoonay k baat hai he is a very knowledgeable man and very good speaker.jaahaan taak tumhari oper wali baat ka talooq hai ke s se pahlay kisi nay kisi aur nay is tanha deen ko paish kia mere bhai Ghamdi sahaab jaisay 1000 se zada main Mufir e quran k list day sakta hoo.Lakin baat yea hai k yea saaab mafoom ul quran hi bayaan kar sakty hai in k baat 100% correct nahi hoo sakty.Ghamdi sahaab ka ek programm Aaj tv se ayaa tha qurbani k mutaliq os main sirf aur sirf wohi mafoom paish kia gaya jo ke qurani haqeeq k khilaaf tha.yahaan in hoonay dual policy ikhtiyaaar ke pahlay qurbani per shih rooshni dali phir is rooshni ko yahoodiyaat aur israiliyaat k zariye paish kar ghalaat tariqay se izhar kia yea haal sirf ghamdi sahaab ka nahi humhary woh mufakir e quran jin hoonay quran ko imami nazaroo se paak rakha phir bhi ghair danishta toor per is ka shikaar hoo gaye.tum nay aksar soona hoo ga ke main pervaizi hoo.yea mujjh per ek tanha ka buhtaan hai Pervaiz sahaab bhi is se na bach sakay in ka mafoom ul quran aur matalib e quran main bhi is k jhalaak nazar aty hai.
Yea hi haal Abdullah chakarwali sahaab ka bhi raha woh bhi Ahle quran hoonay k bawajood apany app ko in riwayatoon se na bacha sakay.baat yea hai ke quran per ijtami toor per hi ghoor hoo sakta hai infaradi toor per nahi aur kisi bhi language main arabhi ka tarjoma hoo hi nahi sakta sirf is ka maffoom bayaan hoo sakta ha kion k araab mahsoosaat se apnay alfaz k buniyaad rakhtay thai is liye arabhi ko lafazi toor per urdu main Fashih kahtay hai..Barhaal chahay woh ghamdi shaab hoo Sir syed Ahmed khan yea Abdullah chakar wali yea Ghulam ahmed pervaiz yea Allama jairaaj puri yea Tamana emadi sahaab yea saab insaan hi thai ghalty in se bhi hoo jaty hai.
i want to mention some name here jo k baray waseeh thai mafoom ul quran main
Sir syed Ahmed Khan
Chirag Ali
Allama jairajpuri *
*Abdullah chakarwali
Tamana emadi
Ghulam ahmed pervaiz
Dr abdul Wadood
Aiman islahi sahaab
Farhi sahaab
Amir Ali
Altaf hussain Hali
Imamul hind Abu kalaam azaad
Allama mashriqi
Aslam Jairaj puri
Ahmed ameen
haasnul bina
Rahmat ullah tariq
sana Ullah amitsari
Abulah Amadi
Abuidh ulllah sindhi
Inaat ullah aasari
rashid raza
syed amir ali
hafiz depti nazir ahmed
mohsin ul malik
muhammad abddah
Agar in main se kisi k bhi book chiye hoo mujhe se con kar laina i will update it for u