Javed Ahmed Ghamdi

[landaleav]

Re: Javed Ahmed Ghamdi

@laeeqkhan

He runs a program on AAJ Tv and I have heard him with my own ears. He denies Hadith of the Prophet :saw:

So I would rather stay away from him. He is a modernist which some people with vested interests want to project as an “enlightened scholar of Islam”.

All he knows is just talk talk talk… Na sir na paer.

Its a simple rule. Anybody deviating from Quran and Sunnah (both) is ofcourse misguided. Even if you take one on isolation from the other - either Quran or Sunnah …you are bound to go estary.

Deviate from what? If deviation is from other scholars, which we have been told in our lifetime, it is not a crime at all. Even our top scholars have deviated from each other, and even on issues like how to find Sunnah, and interpretation of Qur’an. And if you think that Ghamdi reject some hadith because of some reason, then we should consider all our top Muhaddith as “Munkarin -e-hadith”. Imam Malik collected Muwatta. His scrutining is even tighter than Bukhari. He rejected alot of hadith. As I wrote above, Imam Bukhari rejected more than 100,000 hadith.

With all respect, if this is your criteria, you are going to put all these scholars in the list of “Munkarin -e-hadith”, but I think you haven’t read the debate above!