Israel ignores peace talks

As expected from these scums…

Israel ignores peace
Khaled Amayreh, Al-Ahram Weekly, Feb 23, 2008
This article was originally published by Al-Ahram Weekly and is republished with permission.

Hamas has been sending definitive signals of its willingness to sign a dignified truce with Israel in return for its lifting its harsh blockade on the Gaza Strip as well as ending bloody and unrelenting Israeli attacks which wreak death and havoc on the coastal territory’s civilian inhabitants.

Ismail Haniyeh, prime minister of the Hamas-led government in Gaza, said this week that the Islamic movement was “willing and ready to examine any serious proposal that would put an end to Israeli aggression.” Similarly, Hamas spokesman Ayman Taha told reporters in Gaza earlier this week that Hamas welcomed third-party intervention to bring about a ceasefire.

“The ball has always been in the Israeli court, not in our court. The resistance is not the cause, but the effect, of Israeli aggression. If Israel stops its crimes and lifts this oppressive blockade on our people, the resistance would stop,” Taha said.

Taha was responding to remarks made by visiting French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner during a meeting in West Jerusalem with Israeli politician and Meretz leader Yossi Beilin. Kouchner reportedly said that France was willing to play the role of “mediator” or “facilitator” between Hamas and Israel for the purpose of reaching a ceasefire.

Kouchner’s statements represented something of a departure from usual EU policy against making contact with Hamas until it recognises the legitimacy of Zionism (the Jewish character of Israel) and abandon violent resistance to the Israeli occupation. Taha challenged Kouchner to act on his remarks, saying that the French official should visit Gaza to see how things are on the ground.

Hamas has been reluctant to appear publicly as seeking a ceasefire with Israel for fear that this would undermine the movement’s image as a resistance group as well as harm relations with allies in the region. Hamas was also concerned that a ceasefire with Israel would provide Fatah, its arch foe, with valuable propaganda ammunition to discredit the movement.

Increasingly deadly attacks waged by the Israeli army in Gaza, however, met mostly with silence or indifference by the bulk of the international community, appear to have convinced the movement that a ceasefire agreement inclusive of lifting the 20-month-old harsh blockade on Gaza would be an important achievement and popularity booster for Hamas.

One Hamas leader in Gaza told Al-Ahram Weekly that the movement didn’t want to give Israel the propaganda tools it needs to continue its genocidal policy.

“They are trying both to mislead and desensitise world public opinion by claiming that the problem lies in Palestinian rockets originating in Gaza. Meanwhile, they are annihilating entire Palestinian families and are calculating that if the world accepts 10 or 20 Palestinian victims per day, then the world can be desensitised into accepting 50 or even 100 victims per day. It is genocide by retail,” the official said on condition of anonymity.

A second likely reason for Hamas’s willingness to reach a ceasefire with Israel is its deepening rift with the Western- backed Palestinian Authority ¶ in Ramallah. This week, two young Palestinian men confessed on television to having been instructed by Fatah leader Al-Tayeb Abdul-Rahim to murder Haniyeh in return for a hefty sum of money.

The first man told interrogators that he was instructed to detonate a bomb in his hands next to Haniyeh while praying during Friday congregational prayers. The second said he was instructed to kill Haniyeh during a public gathering. Fatah officials in Ramallah dismissed the confessions as “fabrications” but didn’t elaborate further.

What is certain is that mutual distrust between Gaza and Ramallah has reached its highest point since Hamas’s counter- coup against Fatah in Gaza nearly 20 months ago, even reaching suspicion of treachery. Hamas believes that Israel, probably in collusion with Fatah, is planning an all-out onslaught against the Hamas government in Gaza probably in mid- March or early April.

Hamas’s predictions to this effect are not without warrant. Israeli leaders, particularly the manifestly hawkish Defence Minister Ehud Barak, have been promising for some time that Israel will embark on a “huge military move” against Hamas in the near future. Western intelligence sources have also been speaking of a probable Israeli onslaught on Hizbullah as part of Israel’s overall efforts to restore its army’s deterrent value, especially in the wake of the Winograd Report that admitted Israel’s defeat in its war on Lebanon in 2006.

The Ramallah regime of Mahmoud Abbas, while saying publicly it is against an all-out Israeli attack on Gaza, seems inclined to stand aside if military action would lead to the decimation of the Hamas government. Abbas and his Fatah aides realise there is no way to recover Gaza save by defeating Hamas and that this goal can only be achieved by Israel. Abbas also realises that appearing to work in cahoots with Israel would expose the PA as a quisling entity.

From Israel’s point of view, a decisive campaign in Gaza, whatever that means in real terms, is increasingly desirable, especially for Barak. The former Israeli prime minister, who is trying to endear himself to the Jewish Israeli public for electioneering purposes, would like to project himself as the “leader” who was able to defeat Hamas.

Another important goal Barak hopes to achieve is to use Palestinian division to convince or even bully Abbas into accepting a scandalously dismal “peace deal” on Israeli terms. Consequently, it is probable that Israel will not agree to any ceasefire proposal forthcoming from Hamas.

Indeed, more likely is that Israel will continue to provoke Hamas and other Palestinian factions to continue firing homemade projectiles from Gaza onto Israeli settlements in the vicinity. Needless to say, Israel’s main method of provocation is murdering civilians, including children, and creating outrage throughout Gaza.

In this strategy Israel that can always bank on blanket US support, despite its brutal intent and actions. Yet the decimation of Hamas is unlikely to lead to stability, neither in Palestine nor in the region. Added to provocation of the killing of Imad Mughniyah and Israel’s standoff with Hizbullah, an attack on Gaza could trigger a far wider war.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

So Hamas, wants Isreal to lift the blockade and help make Hamas more popular?? Why would Isreal want to do that??

Increasingly deadly attacks waged by the Israeli army in Gaza, however, met mostly with silence or indifference by the bulk of the international community, appear to have convinced the movement that a ceasefire agreement inclusive of lifting the 20-month-old harsh blockade on Gaza would be an important achievement and popularity booster for Hamas.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Israel already made Hamas popular through its anti-Fatah propaganda which they broadcasted during the Palestinian elections. They were quite surprised when their propaganda worked.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Hamas wishes to have a cease fire so they can organize better so that they may reach their goal of pushing Israel into the sea, why wouldn't Israel submit to this?

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Until Hamas repudiates their goal of the destruction of Israel there is nothing to negotiate.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

But I think Israel should be sensible enough to realize that Hamas is in a rock and a hard place

Hamas's charter of the destruction of Israel gives them credibility with the Palestinians

If they change their position then will become like Fatah

So Hamas's offer of a truce should have been taken up by the Israelis

Hamas even said that the truce can go on for 10 years and maybe 50 years, hinting at a permanent peace settlements

Al Sadr in Iraq is operating in the same way. He negotiated a truce with US Forces and recently extended the truce.

Hamas cannot destroy Israel and they know it. They cannot acknowledge Israel's right to exist until Israel start withdrawing from West Bank, share Jerusalem and compensate the Palestinian refugees.

I think once those issues are resolved, Hamas will soften its tone.

So its all a verbal game.

But I think Israel should not be so high and mighty, and should take up Hamas on its offer for a truce.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

^
Make a truce with Hamas and then suddenly it is Islamic Jihad firing the rockets into Israel and what, Israel can't respond to that? The Israeli President has said stop the rocket fire and we will stop responding.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Yes that is the problem

A Hamas truce offer doesn't guarantee that rockets from other groups like Islamic Jihad won't stop falling.

And If Israel retaliates and some bystanders are killed, that will pressure Hamas into cancelling the truce and the cycle continues.

Just sad

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

That's a canard. The same could have been said of the PLO...or any Arab state. It's a non-starter...it is what it is, and this time around Israel is the one rejecting peace and opting for violence. Or are we to pretend Israel is always the victim, and always in the right?

And spare me the "established history/pattern of behavior" argument...it's not as if Israel has a pristine record when it comes to using violence towards a political end.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

The Hamas charter calls for Israels destruction. Hamas thinks it can back Israel into a corner by firing thousands of rockets into Israel over the last year and force them to come to table to form some sort of truce. If they wanted a truce they would stop firing rockets into Israel. And with any truce Israel reserves the right to act if it sees terror preparations taking place. Do you really expect Israel to trust an organization who's charter calls for it's destruction?

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

^ Next time, take the courtesy to read the article before commenting.
Again, ofcourse Israel won't accept, and justice will be brought by any means necessary. (No its not a malcolm x quote, its embedded in the UN charter of human rights!)

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Be honest Crescent, would you rather see peace between Israel and the Palestinians or would you rather see Israel wiped off the map?

Re: Israel ignores peace talks


This "article" is a biased piece of propaganda not worth the bytes of space it takes up.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Interesting post, never expected this from you. However I must agree. Israel must realize (I'm sure it does) the sensitivty Hamas is subject to.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

A truce would be good, if Israel creates itself on a man-made island in the middle of the pacific ocean, sure.

But, for now, its apparent it has no intention to ease its ruthless campaigns against the civilian population of Palestine.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

If the truth is bitter, kindly dont bite into it and go eat something else. :)

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

It's not the truth that's bitter, it's the brainwashed people who see opinion as truth. And actually it's more commiserating than bitter.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

I see, so as long as Israel is pushed into the sea a truce would be fine.

Let it be known Crescent, Israel is not going to leave.

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Here's how it happens:

A peace deal is signed in front of the world after a lot of fighting in which about 2 Israelis die and 5,000 Palestinians die...

A peace accord is reached...

In order to occupy more land for ever growing settlements, Zionists attack Palestinians to uproot them from their ancestral lands, they destroy their homes, destroy their livestock, displace 5,000 Palestinians, kill about 200 or 300, maim and injure about 500 and destroy the farmlands...

Hush, hush, hush...This all happens and no one is the wiser...All access to these areas are blocked to reporters and foreign news crews working in Occupied Palestine...

In desperation and utter helplessness, some father with three children volunteers to sacrifice his life in a last bid to stop these atrocities by the Zionists by strapping a bomb to his chest and instilling some fear into the hearts of Zionists...

Somewhere, someone fires futile Kassam rockets to diverge the attention of the Zionists so the father of three can successfully carry out his desperate bombing operation in hopes of saving a few more homes from decimation...

He succeeds in killing one Zionist and injuring 17...Next day, on front pages in headlines of newspapers across the US and in cover stories on news channels across America, the cowardly, dastardly act of a mindless terrorist is reported who killed dozens and dozens of innocent men women and children...

And that same day, OG, Seminole, M2K and UTD log in to GS and decry the inhuman terrorism of the Palestinians and the utter helplessness and humanity of the Zionists amidst a sea of danger...

Re: Israel ignores peace talks

Let it be known UTD, we know that...That's why it will be made to...