Ismailis in Pakistan

[brahmachari99]

@capatcha

As matter of Principle i.e. whether a belief that there will be other prophets after our holy prophet Hazrat Muhammad PBUH is permissible in islam or not, there has been unanimous consensus amongst the entire muslim Ummah , from the time of Sahabas(the first false prophets emerged during the time of Hazrat Abu Bakar RA) upto this present age that holding such a belief removes one from the fold of Islam, I dont think this is the place to discuss whether this belief is right or wrong or that whether declaring someone non-muslim if he holds such a belief is justified or not.., the important thing is that there is absolute unanimity in Ummah on this principle … can you quote any mainstream Islamic denomination which considers that it is possible for another human being born after our holy prophet PBUH to be bestowed with the honor of Prophethood ?

First of all, you are ABSOLUTELY wrong about this being the unanimous decision among all Muslims since the time of Holy Prophet (SAW). On the contrary, there have been a number of Ulema and Aulia who have believed otherwise. I found this clip on YouTube about Maulana Qasim Nanotvi (founder of Deobandi school of thought):

Please dont try to prove whether your belief is right or wrong just quote the mainstream denomination across the 1400 year time-space dimensions that allow such a belief.

Well, I’d argue that Jamaat Ahmadiyya, for one, was such a mainstream denomination, until you declared them non-Muslims. It’s a great move on your part to first declare everyone who opposes you as non-Muslim, then ask for proof from a Muslim denomination having those beliefs.

The other problem with your argument is if you allow Mullahs to pass verdict on other’s faith, then you have to live with the fact that all the sects of Islam have declared each other as non-Muslim at one point or the other… Shias, Sunnis, Deobandis, Barelvis, etc etc., have all been declared non-Muslim by others. If you are going to believe all such fatwas, then there’s no one left who’s still a Muslim. What makes you so sure you yourself are a Muslim? Whichever sect or school of thought you belong to, you have been declared non-Muslim. So if you follow your own logic, then you yourself are a non-Muslim, and hence have no right to pass judgement whether anyone is a Muslim or not.