If you’re not familiar with Arabic grammar and sciences of hadith(I believe most of us are like that) then many ahadith can confuse you…for example this hadith in Bukhari about making a woman ruler was about a particular woman in Persia but it’s been translated in English wrongly by people.
Queen of Sheba ruled over a nation and they were actually quite successful.
Delivering the message of God is a big responsibility and may be God didn’t want to burden women with this, but it doesn’t mean that God didn’t honour women.
So how many women in the West have created Religions so far?
Just because Aristotle and Plato weren’t female we should stop reading them or we should assume that they stopped women philosophers from rising?
Mary(AS) mother of Jesus(pbuh) was given the status of the best woman and some scholars argue that she was a prophet.
I think we need to keep this gender bias aside.
then it’s surely not Islam’s fault.
May be you needed a detailed reply but I’m very busy for few next weeks so I’m sorry that I had to keep it short.
I hope other posters will carry on the discussion, inshallah.
I’d also like to quote Shaykh Abdal Hakim Murad aka T J winter’s answer to a similar question, he came with some interesting points.
*WHAT ARE THE RIGHTS OF WOMEN IN ISLAM? HOW DOES ISLAM’S VIEW OF MALE-FEMALE EQUALITY DIFFER FROM THE WESTERN VIEW? *
**This question somewhat essentializes Islam and ‘the West’. There is a huge diversity of Muslim opinion here, both ancient and modern; and **‘****the Western view’ really does not exist, since villagers in Venezuela, for instance are Westerners, and so are many ultra-orthodox Jews, and conservative Catholics, and radical Californian feminists; and while the views of all these groups are morally coherent, they are not part of a single ‘Western view’. Thankfully, Islam and the West are both diverse. And of course they overlap: many people, including myself, consider themselves to be both Western and Muslim. ****
Virtually all pre-modern ethical, legal and social systems accepted firm assurances about the respective nature of the two sexes. Women were taken to be nurturers and homemakers, while men were to be earners and warriors. There are clear biological reasons why ancient societies should have favored such a division of labor, and the current sharp debate over the ‘different wiring’ of the male and female brain may clarify this,although it is unlikely to be resolved soon (see, for instance, Ann and Bill Moir, “Why Men Don’t Iron: The Fascinating and Unalterable Differences between Men and Women” [London, 2003]). Whichever way the scientific debate goes, it is evident that our bodies influence our minds, and even our souls, and we can accept this without assuming that one gender is therefore superior to the other.
**Islam is a religion that takes our rootedness in our bodies seriously. We pray with their bodies as well as with our hearts. Turning the body to face Mecca encourages the soul to do the same. Childbearing must have a deep spiritual impact. So Muslims believe that men and women are spiritually different. However the indispensable practices of the religion, including the daily prayers, the hajj pilgrimage to Mecca, and the fasting month of Ramadan, are incumbent on both sexes. For the ancient world, this was a remarkable circumstance, and Muslims are obliged to see it as a sign that women and men are both spiritual beings, with similar spiritual duties (see the Holy Qur’an, chapter 33 verse 35). **
****Some Christian denominations do not accept the validity of women priests. Islam, too, does not recognize the validity of services conducted by women (unless there are no men in the congregation). However this does not exclude women from positions of religious leadership. Thousands of medieval Muslim scholars were women (see Ruth Roded, “Women in Islamic Biographical Collections” [Boulder and London, 1994]). They would teach, preach, and give religious verdicts in the mosque. Many others became saints (Camille Helminski, “Women of Sufism” [New York, 2003]). ****
The lively Muslim feminist movement today likes to point out that since Islam does not call God ‘Father’, and does not believe that God was incarnated in a male body, that Muslims can consider that they are worshipping a gender-neutral deity. This, together with many other factors, ensures the continuing popularity of Islam amongst women. In my own community in the UK, around eighty percent of recent converts have been women. For the U.S. see the remarkable and often moving book by Carol Anway, “Daughters of Another Path: Experiences of American Women Choosing Islam” [Lee’s Summit, MO: sixth edition 2002]).
“The third of Zuckerman’s categories appears to place men at a disadvantage; but in reality this applies only to the secular. In the believer, the virtue described in the Qur’an as taqwa, which is produced from the faith generated in the second category, overcomes this shortfall. The spiritual technologies of Islam allow a compensation for the serotonin lack and a proper disciplining of the darker passions which dwell in the limbic system. The actualised shari‘a is, in a sense, the victory of the frontal cortex, and allows the male to retrieve the balance which is already implicit in the female metabolism. No doubt this is why ‘women are deficient in intellect and religion’. It is not that the Creator has given them innate disadvantages in the quest for understanding and salvation, but rather that He requires men to make more effort to reach their degree of fitra.”
This is how Shaykh Abdal Hakim Murad explains this hadith, you can read the full article here.