Isa (AS) dead or alive. In the light of Quran and Hadith.

[Mr.Popat]

@psyah

Mr. Popat

I apologise as to my lack of availability so I will make my posts less elaborate and put my argument over in bits inshaAllah.

My first reference:
Ascension of Jesus - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

It was an established Christian belief in the Ascension of Isa (AS). Although they believe that Isa (AS) died and was then Resurrected he did eventually go up to heaven in body and soul. You can either refute this reference saying that Christians en masse did not believe this and then you need to provide proof or you can accept they did believe this but deny Christian belief as a valid reference. If you choose to deny this as a valid reference please state your reasons.

The reason why I believe this is not only a valid reference but an essential one is because in the passage from the Qur’an that I will show inshaAllah later the people who are addressed are the People of the Book and it is important to know what their position was at the time of those verses.

Peace psyah,
well, first reference from your side and that too from biblical point of view. I am not concerned with what christian believes are regarding Jesus AS. According to them, He was the son of God. Quran reject this belief and call it a shirk to associate any partner with Allah. The argument here is not what christians have been believing for so long, but rather what Islam has to say about Hazrat Isa AS. I give more importance to Quran than Bible or any other book for that matter. Please provide evidence from Quran or hadith proving his ascension. I am a Muslim, if i were to take the reference you provided as authentic, i would have been a christian. So, please provide evidence from Quran, as i’ve been doing.