Is this true?

[vroom]

Re: Is this true?

@ZeeshanParvez

See, this post of yours is all about Tawassul, not Istigatha.

We need proof for Istigatha from the earlir generations of Muslims - Like saying “Ya Abdul Qaadir Madad” which if allowed would mean we an also say

Ya Essa Madad

Ya Abdul Qadir Sheyin lillah requires a bit more then just an acknowledgement that there is room for istigatha in Islam, as is what we are discussing here

For that you need to believe certain things like life after death, and freedom for the slaves of Allah in the lands [all of which Allah is the Owner]

• I mean these are simple things but to really appreciate them

However purpose here to affirm istigatha in the above passages contains the words ‘’…**O Muhammad! I turn through you to my lord, that He fulfil my need…” **

This is istigatha

Drinking water which has come into contact with the Garment Sharif or Blessed Hair is also like istigatha, but not spoken words