Re: Is this true?
Great, Since you are familiar with it - I can expect a refutation rather then threats to come back with something, yeah?
OK another subject kissing thumbs. Kissing thumbs has been approved by some scholars. The hadith regarding it may be weak, but for us we are allowed to do amal that are approved from weak narrations. Imam Ibn Abidin Shaami and others have approved of the action, many people choose to do it.
I know what the scholars have said on some of the subjects, That is why i have accepted them as fellow Sunnis like me! Cos - they certainly wouldn’t be acceptable after that to you - imagine ‘‘forget’’ istigtha lets do it silently from thought to thought, from heart to heart!
Btw - the aim of the site is to disapprove the action being ‘‘shirk’’ in it of itself, and the actions being accepted in the community because that is what your like minded people, and those effected by you need as an answer
What is not shirk with the living being a principle for not being shirk when one has passed away is not Qiyas. It is one of our principles
None of your reply is really worth answering
Yet, you go through the trouble as seen in this thread .
Really, can’t debate when we have those sources. Guess its simply your beliefs for you and mine for mine! We shall find out what happens on the Day of Judgement. Chao!
Actually, I have now adopted that approach for your comments after seeing how incompetent your sources are as seen in this thread.