Re: Is this true?
Are you confusing arabs for najdis? The hadiths I have presented earlier are from Arabs, the sahaba, and our Hadith collectors
Meaning istighatha was never prohibited, and this is the view of orthodox mainstream Muslims
It is only a practice and not a matter of aqeedah among people who are of one aqeedah. Where as some forms and reasons for prohibition would mean a difference of aqeedah
This thread was an attempt to get back at me for what you saw as me labelling you as hypocrite or disbeliever. You stated this. Also you took offence at me pointing out that subjects such as istighatha and our Grave culture are beliefs of mainstream Muslims. Also you must have agreed with the protestant christian in what he said regarding the Muslims and specifically Imam Ahmad Raza Khan Imam e Ahle Sunnat
You called Imam Subki Rehmatullah Alaih as a ‘‘granddaddy’’ - which is indicative of what type of emotional state you are in with regards to the beliefs of mainstream Muslims.
This thread was not initiated by a genuine seeker of knowledge or clarification.
My attitude is not effected by your praying behind Barelvis, it is effected by what you write. What you wrote aimed or desired to put the fatwa of kufr and Shirk upon mainstream islam and its adherents such as imam Ahmad Raza Khan and Imam Subki, and others
Oh man you getting all emotional again!!!
It’s ok. Well know how UNAUTHENTIC your sources were. So, I don’t think I need to waste any more time on you.
Next time hope you will find a website which knows how to translate and a video which does not have a coconut in it saying things which are basically lies!!!
And please a lesson in Husn Zann which I know is difficult for your sect…
And no I don’t take back anything I said!!!
