My dear friend Sherazz, the hadiths you presented is about the tarawee namaaz, I thought you were going to present the hadiths about the according to you that Umar added “namaaz is better than sleep” into the Azaan.
Anyhow, that hadith you wrote is about tarawee. Prophet Mohammad did prayed this tarawee namaaz behind a qari, after 3 nights he said he was afraid that it will become obligatory(farzz) so he stoped doing it. After he died, there was no chance of something becomeing obligatory or farzz to do, because “wahi” stoped coming. What Hazrat Umar did was to start the practice that Mohammad use to do, because there was no risk of it becoming obligatory(ferzz). So, it turns out it was not a “bid’ah” but a good practice that was also done by Prophet Mohammad.
Other hadiths about pointing fingers, was also practiced by Mohammad(pbuh). Its in hadiths book, maybe not in yours.
http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/smile.gif
Many things today shias do which were never done by Mohammad. If you browse through shia hadiths books you will see, the importance is given to what Imaams say and not what Prophet taught us. For example: Allah says in quran that only he knows the unseen, future; but in shia hadiths books it says that Imaams know the future and unseen. - That is just one of the things that contradict with quran, there are many more. - How can you call something Islam, when it totally contradicts with teachings of quran/islam?
My dear friend Sherazz: My friendly advice to you is that you read your books and see how they contradict with quran. And decide your self what is true, quran or books written by your Imaams. Even Imaams should be following what Allah revealed and what Mohammad taught and not putting his own desires and wills into the books and naming them Islam. I am sure you take what Imaam tells you as true, if he tells you that he knows the future, do you tell him that it says in quran that only Allah knows the future? You do not ask or argue out of respect and blind love. We should investigate and read quran as much as possible, so we might not be fooled by personal clames and desires of other humans. I hope, you do not have any wrath against me, I am only asking for investigation of what you hear and read in the books and see if it is ok from the quran. Thanks
http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/smile.gif
Take it easy.
http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/smile.gif
V~V~VHe came, He saw, He conqueredV~V~V**
----*Priest-OF- Painful Truth*----
