Is Sufi Islam a compromise with Indian Culture?

[Ali_Syed]

Re: Is Sufi Islam a compromise with Indian Culture?

@muqawwee123

check google you will find stuff calling Prophet intolerant for the way he dealt with Jews who were involved in conspiracies against Muslims. Thats a different topic in itself. The point is each ideology consider other opposite ideology unfit. There is stuff popular among people who follow so called tasawwuf, which is full of hatred against orthodox Islam and sharia. I’ve once shared in these forums how so called sufis make mockery of basic principles (Haj, Namaz, etc) of Islam.

I do agree with psyah’s point of view (he keeps on repeating in such discussion) that there should be no tareeqa without sharaia, but unfortunately in practice (at least what I’ve seen) that is not the case. A mosque near a dargah is normally occupied by fewer namazi than the crow available on dargah at namaz timings.

Maybe you are talking of Bulleh Shah? Otherwise I cant think (barring some uneducated people) of anyone who’d make fun of Islamic rituals and then consider himself a Muslim.

I have never come across any Sufi, who believes that he does not need to obey Islams teachings. Having said that one can educate those people who might believe that they do not need to worship as their peer would get their sins forgiven on judgement day, this is no different to some other people who consider that they can kill innocent people on the orders of their ameer (again to reach jannah). In fact the latter is worse.