Re: Is Sufi Islam a compromise with Indian Culture?
its not matter of finding bad or good as you made it yourself but its matter of finding what is allowed in Islam and what is not.
seculsion was allowed in Christianity but it was disallowed in Islam as revelation was updated. so if Prophet were doing seclusion BEFORE being entrusted with Prophethood it would be allowed then.
btw, your question makes no sense. do you believe seculsion is allowed in Islam?