Is Sufi Islam a compromise with Indian Culture?

[muqawwee123]

Re: Is Sufi Islam a compromise with Indian Culture?

@khoji

dus bibiyon ki kahani is not sufi related.
Qawwali is hamd/naat in melody and music, which is present in many Muslim countries in the world. Not just subcontinent. There is no link with Bhajan or whatever.

I think somebody is misguiding you.

Not exactly.. The kind of Qawwali that is present in India was invented during Nizam u din Auliya / Ameer Khusro period and quite distinguished from nasheed/ naat prevalent in other Muslim countries.

Dus bibiyon ki kahani might not be sufi tradition, but it is followed in those circles who are very much into sufiism (to be specific Barelvis).. This is very much similar with Hindu Punch Kaniya and I don’t think that this 5/10 beebiyon ki kahani is that popular in other Muslim countries.