The logic which is given against organ donation in Islam is this:
"This body you have does not belong to you , it is Allah key Amanat (It is something given to you by Allah for safe keeping - this is best translation I could come up with ). So since you are not owner of your body then you cannot decide about what happens to you after you die."
It is used against organ donation , cosmetic surgery, plucking of eyebrows etc etc.
Then there are these ahadees which are used against organ donation:
Utter and Complete Paindoo Production.
That verse is irrelevant to what you are implying: "organ donation is mutilating of a body inspired by Satan."
If I die and if my kidney's can ease someone's pain, my heart can help someone survive, and if my liver can help someone drink liquids...then I will be proud of that sacrifice. It is stupidity to assume that satan is making me do it.
And its also irrelevant to mention your hadees, since not everyone really cares about those things.
That verse is irrelevant to what you are implying: "organ donation is mutilating of a body inspired by Satan."
If I die and if my kidney's can ease someone's pain, my heart can help someone survive, and if my liver can help someone drink liquids...then I will be proud of that sacrifice. It is stupidity to assume that satan is making me do it.
And its also irrelevant to mention your hadees, since not everyone really cares about those things.
And very paindo mola jut has ignore post # 10 by me for the rebuttal of this stance.
i read tht a doctor can operate on you if it’s a matter of life and death..
kair, i remembered a story
There was this really religious guy who was stuck in a Hurricane everyone else ran for there lifes and where saved, and this one man stayed in his house and said “i believe in my Allah, he will save me and no one else” so he stayed in his house and waited for Allah to save him.
There was a knock at the door and this man came and said to him " come with me and u will be ok" the man replied “No my Allah will send someone for me” the man went away…
A few hours later there was another knock at the door this time a man came on a boat becoz of the high waters, and said to the man" come with me and i will save you" The man replied again" No i believe in Allah and he will show me the sign tht everything will be ok" and sent the man away and waited for the Sign on Allah.
A few hours later - The waters where so high that the man had to sit on his roof, a helicopter came this time and said to the man “stop being stupid and get in and we will save you, other wise ur gonna die” the man replied back " go away and leave me i believe in my Allah and he will send someone to save me" the helicopter went away and the man drowned …
when the man went up to Allah he asked Allah “Allah i believed in you, and i waited for u to save me, but u let me die. Why did u let me die?” Allah replied and said to the man “i sent my People to u not once, not twice but three times and u turned them away what other sign was u wating for? i didnt let u die, u let ur self die”…
Re: Is Organ Donation Allowed? [split from: Tough Decisions in life]
the story shared above does prove that v should help from our fellows as they are a sort of helping hand from ALLAH and they extend the blessed help from him. so, i feel that donating your very part of body is the best possible service of help to any being and there should b no discussion at this point as Allah loves the helping hands so one should go for them wherever one finds them.
Re: Is Organ Donation Allowed? [split from: Tough Decisions in life]
^ Its a good example though of things we miss. What else are we waiting for? Divine intervention? A lightning bolt? He sends us help in practical ways...its upto us to recognize it.
Re: Is Organ Donation Allowed? [split from: Tough Decisions in life]
The way I look at it, the fact that we are wise and talented enough to carry out organ transplant to save lives is in fact an appreciation of the infinite wisdom of our creator. To save someone's life is a prayer itself.
OMG I read this story on a Christian website , it has been musharaff ba Islam by some very enthusiastic Muslim or Musharaff ba Christianity by some very enthusiastic Christian.
Re: Is Organ Donation Allowed? [split from: Tough Decisions in life]
^I remembered what i could of the story, was told to me along time ago. i am not trying to convinve anyone by it, I thought Organ donation was haram until i read this thread, and i find it very interesting to read posts "for" and "against" it...
^I remembered what i could of the story, was told to me along time ago. i am not trying to convinve anyone by it, I thought Organ donation was haram until i read this thread, and i find it very interesting to read posts "for" and "against" it...
so i would love to read ur story too:)
You are so nice.
I will tell you bed time story. Its a serious issue so there is no need to post fake stories. I won't tell you here.
What kind of story you like sad, happy, or unthinkable.
Re: Is Organ Donation Allowed? [split from: Tough Decisions in life]
Hum bola hum tumko yahan par jhoota kahani naheen sunaay ga.
Muzhab kay maamlay main jhoota story hum naheen sunata hai.
Agar tum sunna chahta hai story to hum tumko bedtime story zaroor sunaay ga. Bohat dilchasp ho ga. Sirf humko bata do tum kaisa story pasand karta hai. Dukh bhari dastan, Khushion ki kahani kay soch say bhi upper ki kahani.
i read tht a doctor can operate on you if it’s a matter of life and death..
^^^ hehe